Batting Out Of Order

Duffy-Wilson-Sanchez? Or Duffy-Sanchez-LaRoche? The Pirates’ lineup has been getting a lot of attention as of late (such as in the P-G here and here, on here, and at WHYGAVS and Honest Wagner), as there’s not too much else to talk about in the world of hardball at the end of January. The Bucs won’t bring in any other significant pieces (save possibly another starting pitcher), so everyone’s talking about the puzzle we can build with the players we already have.
I’m not the first to do it–and I certainly won’t be the last–but here’s the order David Pinto’s Lineup Analysis tool spits out given our current personnel and their ZiPS projections:
Freddy Sanchez
Jason Bay
Chris Duffy
Adam LaRoche
Xavier Nady
Jack Wilson
Jose Bautista
Ronny Paulino
That’s one of three that would amount to 4.819 runs per game, or about 780 runs this season. But since Jim Tracy’s not Tony La Russa, we won’t see Zach Duke batting eighth or Bay hitting second. On April 2nd in Houston, barring injury, we’ll see Duffy-Wilson-Sanchez-LaRoche-Bay-Nady-Bautista/Castillo-Paulino. And I’m fine with that. I won’t debate the merits of Wilson hitting second or eighth. Why?
Because I can guarantee you September 30th against St. Louis, we’ll see an entirely different order.
Let’s head over to Baseball Reference for a moment and examine the orders that took the field in 2006. Scroll to the bottom of the page to see a summary: Over a 162 game season, the Pirates used 121 different orders. Sure, there was roster turnover, a different starting pitcher each day, etc. But the most common lineup only appeared in six games. For comparison, the Cardinals used 131 orders. The Yankees, with the DH, used 120.
On Opening Day 2006, Jim Tracy penned this linuep:
Chris Duffy
Jack Wilson
Sean Casey
Jason Bay
Joe Randa
Jeromy Burnitz
Jose Castillo
Humberto Cota
Oliver Perez
By October 1st, he was using an order similar to the one we’ll see this year, only substituting LaRoche for Ryan Doumit. When Duffy struggled early on, we saw Nate McLouth in the first slot. Eventually, Jose Bautista took over the center field and leadoff duties. Freddy Sanchez broke onto the scene and flip-flopped between third and fifth. Sean Casey got hurt (and then traded), cuing the entrances of Craig Wilson and Xavier Nady.
Creating a batting order isn’t an exact science. Tracy plays the hot hand. In his first nine games leading off, Bautista either got a hit, scored a run, or both. He pulled an oh-for-four in the tenth, so the skipper switched to McLouth. Nate then put together an eight-game streak of his own. Wilson’s on-base percentage was .347 after the All-Star break (compared to .293 before), so he kept hitting second. Seems simple to me.
The 2007 lineup isn’t written in stone. Tracy’s suggested that LaRoche will only hit cleanup against righties, and he’ll drop to fifth for lefties. If Chris Duffy sputters out of the gate again, he won’t play. If Jack Wilson hits .220, we’ll see Bautista or Sanchez move up to second.
It’s commonplace to second-guess the manager, but in this instance, I think it’s a waste of time. You can tell a great deal about the game of baseball from numbers and statistics. But there’s still some feel to the sport. Tracy has to know whose bat is about to catch on fire and who’s getting worn down. He has to predict if shifting his batting champ from third to second will put a hole in his game. I’ll admit that Jack will be stealing at-bats from Jason for the first few weeks of the season. But we’re in elementary school math territory–guess, test and revise. If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again.
Maybe Bay put it best when he made this quote to Dejan Kovacevic:

“You know what?” he continued. “A lot of this is going to hinge on Duffy, anyway. If the top of the lineup isn’t working, things will have to shuffled.”

It’s a work in progress–and it’s part of the reason we’ll go to the ballpark from April ’til October. The games aren’t played on paper. If they were, I’d be a Yankees fan.

Share This Article

Downfall of the Fam-A-Lee – Part 1

Next Story »


  • Matt

    I kind of like the idea of Bautista hitting 2nd. He draws some walks, and I think he would benefit from seeing more pitches to hit with Freddy, LaRoche, and Bay behind him. I still think Freddy belongs there, but Bautista would be a better fit than Jack.

  • pie

    Wouldn’t it be weird if Duffy suddenly starts to hit HRs? that means we’ll have to put him 5th or 6th in the lineup.

  • Ryan adamsWeblog

    […] “>Batting Out Of Order Extremely interesting post. I’ve included it to my bookmarks.DuffyWilsonSanchez Or DuffySanchezLaRoche The Pirates#8217 lineup has been getting a lot of attention as of late such as in the PG here and here, on here, and at WHYGAVS and Honest Wagner, as there#8217s not too much else to talk about in the world of hardball at the end of …My opinion is that this post should be rememberedLink to original article […]

  • Pittsburgh Lumber Co. | MVN – Most Valuable Network » Blog Archive » Tracy’s Tende

    […] I stumbled on this post at Chronicles of the Lads, a Los Angeles Angeles blog, while perusing the work of Tom Tango (a sabermetrician associated with the Marcels projections).  Tom talked in mathspeak before coming to the conclusion that “All-in-all, it’s likely that the Angels’ bunting was a wash.”  I thought to myself, “Self:  This could be directly related to that post you made about the 2007 batting order.  You should look into this bunting business.”  So that’s what I did. […]

Latest Analysis

  • Jose Tabata

    The Details of Jose Tabata’s New Swing

    1 day ago

    On Friday I wrote about how Jose Tabata talked to Marlon Byrd over the off-season, aimed at changing his swing to add some leverage, lift the ball, ...

    Read More
  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    What Led to Keon Broxton’s Breakout Year in Altoona?

    2 days ago

    Keon Broxton used to be one of the top prospects in the Arizona Diamondbacks’ farm system. Baseball America ranked him as high as tenth in the system ...

    Read More
  • Adrian Sampson

    Don’t Forget About This Pitcher When Creating Your Pirates Dream Rotation

    3 days ago

    If you’re setting up a dream rotation for the Pittsburgh Pirates in the not-too-distant future, then you’re going to be throwing out names like Tyler Glasnow, Gerrit ...

    Read More
  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    Jose Tabata Changed His Swing After Talking With Marlon Byrd

    4 days ago

    Yesterday, Jose Tabata put one on the roof of the batting cages over the left-field fence at Pirate City. Today, he added two more. By that pattern, ...

    Read More
  • Antonio Bastardo

    How Ray Searage is Trying to Fix Antonio Bastardo’s Control Issues

    4 days ago

    Tony Watson has established himself as one of the best left-handed relievers in the game. Out of 142 qualified relievers last year, he ranked 21st in WAR, ...

    Read More
  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    Q&A: Will PNC Park Burn Down When Neil Walker Eventually Leaves?

    4 days ago

    Last week we started a Q&A article that will run every Friday. Right after the first article went up, we got a lot more questions. Normally I’ll ...

    Read More
  • Browse More Articles