Did the BBWAA put in the right guys last Tuesday? Would you have done anything differently?
Randy from Buried Treasure:
Ripken and Gwynn were clearly first ballot candidates. Im in the school of thought that says Ripken is overrated, but hes a great player nonetheless. If it were up to me, Blyleven, Dawson, Gossage, Morris and Lee Smith would be in. I also would have voted for McGwire. I argued on my blog that by comparing Mac to Harmon Killebrew and Eddie Mathews (neither of whom were first ballot inductees), you can make the case that Macs numbers, with or without steroids, dont warrant first ballot induction. What happened yesterday set a dangerous precedent. The whisper of scandal is sometimes worse than the scandal itself. Perhaps Mac should, like Pete Rose, write a tell-all book and release it this time next year. Im not trying to say that McGwire shouldve taken illegal steroids, if in fact he did. He was morally wrong, if he did do it, even if he was competiti...