Arbitration Values Part 1: Paul Maholm

The Pirates reached an agreement this week with four of their six arbitration eligible players, leaving only Paul Maholm and Nate McLouth unsigned. Going in to the off-season, Pittsburgh wanted to sign each player to a long term extension, but talks broke down quickly for McLouth, and have been quiet for Maholm. All sides have now submitted offers for the 2009 season, with each player about a million dollars off what the Pirates are offering.

Each player has requested $3.8 M, while the Pirates have offered $2.75 M to McLouth, and $2.65 M to Maholm. If you are unfamiliar with the arbitration process, here are the options going forward:

1. One side could accept the other sides’ offer (unlikely)

2. The two sides could negotiate and meet in the middle (common)

3. The two sides could go to an arbitration hearing, argue the case for their offer, and let the arbiter decide which offer is more appropriate (teams don’t usually like to do this because it can lead to ill-feelings from the player when the team makes their case)

The arbitration process is guaranteed, unless the two sides work out a deal beforehand. One could argue that the Pirates are foolish to potentially hurt the relationships with two of their top players, but that assumes that the players offers are fair value. To determine which side has the fairest offer, let’s take a look at each player’s stats to date, plus the first year arbitration totals of some other players around the league. We will start with Paul Maholm, and cover Nate McLouth in a later post.

Paul Maholm

2005: 3-1, with a 2.19 ERA and a 1.17 WHIP in 41.1 IP
2006: 8-10, with a 4.76 ERA and a 1.61 WHIP in 176 IP
2007: 10-15, with a 5.03 ERA and a 1.43 WHIP in 177.2 IP
2008: 9-9, with a 3.71 ERA and a 1.28 WHIP in 206.1 IP
Total: 30-35, with a 4.30 ERA and a 1.41 WHIP in 601.1 IP

Maholm did well in his debut in 2005, although those numbers can be chalked up to his first time through the league. In 2006 he struggled with a 4.76 ERA, which probably should have been worse considering the 1.61 WHIP. He did even worse in 2007 with a 5.03 ERA, although the WHIP improved.

Last year Maholm had a breakthrough season, posting a 3.71 ERA and a 1.41 WHIP. This performance is enough to make him the “ace” of the staff going in to the 2009 season (although I use the term “ace” loosely, because I don’t think Maholm ranks up there with other aces like Tim Lincecum and Cole Hamels).

I’ve seen the argument made that if Zach Duke can get $2.2 M for his 4.82 ERA and 1.50 WHIP in 2008, then Maholm should get much more than $2.65 M. The important thing to consider is that this process doesn’t take in to consideration one season, but the entire body of work leading up to now. Comparing the two players:

Duke: 26-39, with a 4.40 ERA and a 1.50 WHIP in 592.1 IP
Maholm: 30-35, with a 4.30 ERA and a 1.41 WHIP in 601.1 IP

Those career numbers are very similar, and each player took a similar career path (called up in 2005, remained in the rotation since) so the players are about even. Maholm has slightly better numbers, which makes sense why the Pirates offered him about half a million more. The major difference between the two players is that Duke has struggled the last two years (5.08 ERA, 1.59 WHIP), while Maholm is coming off a great 2008 season.

Even if we were going to discount his other seasons and only count Maholm’s one good season, how does that compare to other arbitration decisions over the last few years?

James Shields: Signed a contract extension after two full seasons where he combined for an 18-16 record, a 4.22 ERA, and a 1.23 WHIP. Will make $2.5 M in his fourth year.

Scott Kazmir: Received $3.785 M in his first season of arbitration last year, which is right below what Maholm is asking. However, Kazmir posted a 35-29 record with a 3.65 ERA, and a 1.40 WHIP in 570.2 IP before getting this deal.

Brandon Webb: After going 10-9 with a 2.85 ERA his rookie season, Webb signed an extension that would pay him $2 M in his fourth season. Before the 2006 season (his fourth year), he signed another extension that changed that contract to $2.5 M, after posting a 31-37 record, with a 3.35 ERA and a 1.31 WHIP in 617.2 IP.

Felix Hernandez: Hernandez recently agreed to a $3.8 M deal for the 2009 season, his first season of arbitration. Like Maholm, Hernandez was called up in 2005, and has remained in the rotation since that point. Unlike Maholm, Hernandez has gone 39-36, with a 3.80 ERA, and a 1.32 WHIP in 666.1 IP.

When comparing these pitchers to Maholm, I’d have to say that the best match would be Shields. Hernandez and Kazmir had a much better track record before getting about what Maholm is asking for, and that wasn’t the product of one good season. Shields had a 4.86 ERA in 2006, then bounced back with a 3.85 ERA in 2007, before getting his contract that paid him $2.5 M for his first year of arbitration.

I would guess that at this point, if the Pirates and Maholm went to arbitration, the Pirates would win, simply because Maholm has not done enough over his 3+ year career to warrant a similar salary as guys like Scott Kazmir and Felix Hernandez. His stats to date are similar to James Shields, who got $2.5 M, and slightly better than his teammate Zach Duke, who just got $2.2 M. Thus, I’d say the $2.65 M is an appropriate value for what Maholm has done so far in his career.

Share This Article

Tim Williams

Tim is the owner and editor in chief of Pirates Prospects. He started the site in January 2009, and turned it into his full time job during the 2011 season. Prior to starting Pirates Prospects, Tim worked with, providing MLB, NHL, and NFL coverage to various national media outlets, including ESPN Insider, USA Today, Yahoo Sports, and the Wall Street Journal. He also writes the annual Prospect Guide, which is sold through the site. Tim lives in Bradenton, where he provides live coverage all year of Spring Training, mini camp, instructs, the Bradenton Marauders, and the GCL Pirates.

Pena In, Perez Out, and a Dominican Twist

Next Story »

Arbitration Values Part 2: Nate McLouth

Latest Analysis

  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    Jose Tabata Changed His Swing After Talking With Marlon Byrd

    3 hours ago

    Yesterday, Jose Tabata put one on the roof of the batting cages over the left-field fence at Pirate City. Today, he added two more. By that pattern, ...

    Read More
  • Antonio Bastardo

    How Ray Searage is Trying to Fix Antonio Bastardo’s Control Issues

    5 hours ago

    Tony Watson has established himself as one of the best left-handed relievers in the game. Out of 142 qualified relievers last year, he ranked 21st in WAR, ...

    Read More
  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    Q&A: Will PNC Park Burn Down When Neil Walker Eventually Leaves?

    8 hours ago

    Last week we started a Q&A article that will run every Friday. Right after the first article went up, we got a lot more questions. Normally I’ll ...

    Read More
  • Tyler Glasnow

    The Change That Will Help Tyler Glasnow Reach His Upside

    1 day ago

    The 2011 draft made headlines for the Pittsburgh Pirates for two main reasons. They selected Gerrit Cole first overall, and gave him a record-setting bonus of $8 ...

    Read More
  • Jameson Taillon

    The Next Steps in Jameson Taillon’s Tommy John Rehab Process

    2 days ago

    Jameson Taillon threw a bullpen session yesterday, which I outlined in the daily recap. Taillon is still in “rehab mode” as Clint Hurdle put it, which means ...

    Read More
  • Sean Rodriguez

    The Keys to Sean Rodriguez Being a Productive Hitter

    3 days ago

    The Pittsburgh Pirates added Sean Rodriguez at a high cost this off-season. They traded promising pitching prospect Buddy Borden to the Rays, getting Rodriguez in return after ...

    Read More
  • Browse More Articles