Miguel Angel Sano, the top prospect in the international signing period, and prime target by the Pittsburgh Pirates, has signed a deal with the Minnesota Twins for $3.15 M, according to several sources. If you ask me, the Pirates got a raw deal from Sano’s agent, Rob Plummer. Let’s review the timeline here:
Pirates got a raw deal with Sano
UPDATE 12:56 AM: Check out this post by DK on the PBC Blog. A great recap of the entire timeline of events, including some stuff we haven’t heard already. And for those of you who feel this will hurt the Pirates in Latin America, Jorge Arangure says this will help the Pirates, as trainers and agents now know the team is willing to spend.
-The Pirates opened the international signing period with a $2 M offer. They were the only team reported to make an offer.
-The Pirates upped their offer to $2.6 M in August, still with no other teams publicly bidding.
-St. Louis voided their deal with Wagner Mateo, who had received $3.1 M, the previous top bonus on the market this year.
-Not long after, word got out that Sano lowered his asking price.
The news today that Sano signed with the Twins was a huge surprise, as the Twins weren’t mentioned as serious bidders, in the sense that they had made such an offer. It seems that the Twins made the offer today, and Plummer accepted it. A series of Tweets by ESPN’s Jorge Arangure lead me to further believe that the Pirates got the short end of the stick here:
NOTE: All of these Tweets are from Jorge Arangure
Tweet #1: Sano Orioles offer never went past $2.5m. Pirates offer was $2.6.
Tweet #2: Basically, the Pirates didn’t sign Sano because of the fractured relationship between the Pirates and Sano’s agent
Tweet #3: My read of the situation is that the agent did not like the close relationship the Pirates had with Sano’s family
Tweet #4: The Pirates were absolutely stunned by Sano’s signing today. They had no clue this was coming.
Tweet #5: From my understanding, the Orioles were given a chance to match. The Pirates were not given that chance.
There’s two things to look at here: before the Twins offer, and after the Twins offer.
The Pirates were the high bidders for a long time. They were also the only bidders for a long period of time. The Pirates had out-bid the Orioles by $100 K. Plummer rejected the Pirates’ offer, wanting more, and saying Sano had interest from other teams.
Here’s the situation. Sano did have interest, but he didn’t have bidders. That’s a huge difference. Interest doesn’t imply a certain price, which means the Pirates would have been foolish to outbid themselves, since they had the high bid at the time.
Then comes the Twins offer. Arangure reports that the Pirates were shocked by this, having no clue it was coming. He also reports that Plummer gave the Orioles the chance to match, but didn’t give the same opportunity to the Pirates.
This isn’t like the draft signing process. Agents in Latin America have a lot of influence in where their client can go, which means Plummer can pretty much cut the Pirates out of the bidding, and that’s what appears to have happened here.
This isn’t a case of the Pirates being cheap. This is a case of the Pirates getting a raw deal. We don’t know if the Pirates would have matched the offer to Sano, because they were never given the opportunity. You could say that they could have offered more initially, but that’s in hindsight, and wasn’t the right move at the time. Not only were the Pirates the high bidders, but they were the only bidders for the longest time.
I’m sure the Pirates assumed that Plummer would get a chance to match any offer, probably because a month ago, Plummer agreed to give them such chance, according to Dejan Kovacevic. What’s even more interesting is that, in that same post, Plummer says that he wouldn’t have signed with the Pirates, even if they came back with more money, because he appreciates how the Twins dealt with him.
Bottom line, the Pirates got a raw deal by an agent who developed a grudge against the management group, and missed out on a top prospect as a result. It’s no wonder why the Red Sox and Yankees don’t deal with Rob Plummer.
More on Sano from other sites: