With Duke Cut Free, MLB Should Consider Fixing Arbitration

May 1, 2010 Los Angeles, CA..starting pitcher Zach Duke of the Pittsburgh Pirates in action during the Major League Baseball game between the Pittsburgh Pirates and the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium May 01, 2010 in Los Angeles, California..The Dodgers defeated the Pirates, 5-1.Louis Lopez/CSM.

Zach Duke - Louis Lopez/CSM (Zumapress)

With the news that the Pirates have designated Zach Duke, Andy LaRoche and Delwyn Young for assignment, I’m reminded of a long-since-gone article I penned at the old Most Valuable Network site when the Pirates released Josh Fogg rather than re-sign him to a salary that was inflated by arbitration.

In the case of Duke, the article states Pittsburgh figured they would be on the hook for $6 million in 2011 for the arbitration eligible Duke (he made $4.3 million in 2010). Of course, he isn’t worth it and he won’t command anything near that on the open market. So, what has arbitration accomplished? Nothing positve. Duke, who has known just one organization in his career, is packing up and looking for work and likely staring at a pay cut. A community that has grown accustomed to the affable starter is, as Jerry Seinfeld pointed out, rooting for laundry.

Back in 2006, Fogg signed a one year deal with Colorado that paid him (according to baseball-reference.com) $450,000. He had earned over $2 million in 2005 from Pittsburgh. After a solid (well, solid in the sense that it was a typical year for Fogg), the Rockies gave him a hefty raise for 2007.

How about a fix? I would like to see an ‘offer sheet’ type of free agency for these types of players. The team that holds his contract can refuse arbitration and allow the open market to bid on him. The incumbent team could then pay some percentage over the best offer (say 25%) in an attempt to retain the player in question. But the player has the right of refusal. If he wants to move on, he can do so. If he wants to stay with his current team, he can do that as well with 25% more pay. The player, who is certain to have a decrease in salary, has a choice over new surroundings or a slightly smaller pay cut with his old team. Teams have better conrol over personnel and expense. The only loser is the union which seems to prefer artificially inflating salaries over maintaining some semblance of continuity in a player’s career.

Share This Article

Randy Linville

Randy is currently living and thriving in suburban Dayton, OH with his wife and two kids. He was raised in Cincinnati, OH and attended Anderson High School. He went to Miami University (Ohio) and received a degree in Paper Science Engineering from MU. He is a devout Christian and a pop culture buff. He coaches his son’s baseball and basketball teams and his daughters softball and basketball teams. Randy has been a Pirates fan since the late 1970s and has fond memories of the 1979 World Series team. He began blogging for Most Valuable Network in 5/2004 after stumbling across a help-wanted sign for a Pirates blogger. He wrote for Pittsburgh Lumber Co. until the site merged with Pirates Prospects in 2/2011.

Pittsburgh Pirates 2010 Rule 5 Eligible Players

Next Story »

2010 Rule 5 Draft Eligible Players: Position Players

Latest Analysis

  • Tarpley Brault

    Will the Snider Trade Result in the Pirates Finally Having a Left-Handed Starting Prospect?

    7 hours ago

    Despite adding plenty of pitching through the draft over the last several years, the Pittsburgh Pirates have been short on the amount of quality left-handed pitching in their ...

    Read More
  • Connor Joe 2

    Meet Connor Joe: The First Round Pick You Know Nothing About

    12 hours ago

    This site is now in its seventh year of existence. For the last four years, I’ve been doing this full-time, allowing me to see every affiliate throughout the year, along ...

    Read More
  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    What is the Difference Between Mel Rojas and Keon Broxton?

    1 day ago

    Mel Rojas Jr. was drafted by the Pittsburgh Pirates in the third round of the 2010 MLB draft. The son of the former big league closer had ...

    Read More
  • Jose Tabata

    The Details of Jose Tabata’s New Swing

    3 days ago

    On Friday I wrote about how Jose Tabata talked to Marlon Byrd over the off-season, aimed at changing his swing to add some leverage, lift the ball, ...

    Read More
  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    What Led to Keon Broxton’s Breakout Year in Altoona?

    4 days ago

    Keon Broxton used to be one of the top prospects in the Arizona Diamondbacks’ farm system. Baseball America ranked him as high as tenth in the system ...

    Read More
  • Adrian Sampson

    Don’t Forget About This Pitcher When Creating Your Pirates Dream Rotation

    5 days ago

    If you’re setting up a dream rotation for the Pittsburgh Pirates in the not-too-distant future, then you’re going to be throwing out names like Tyler Glasnow, Gerrit ...

    Read More
  • Browse More Articles