What’s wrong with Andrew McCutchen?

Dave Arrigo - Pittsburgh Pirates

Clearly, Andrew McCutchen is slumping. After a hot start on the season’s opening road trip, he has hit .162/.279/.270 in his past 86 plate appearances. There is little to worry about at this point, as we are only a month into the season. He had a .286/.365/.459 line in 1146 career major league plate appearances entering the year, so there is no reason to be concerned over a rough 30-day stretch. That being said, let’s take a look at why he is struggling so badly.

First of all, let’s compare his overall numbers to his first two seasons.

Season PA AVG OBP SLG wOBA
2009 493 .286 .365 .471 .368
2010 653 .286 .365 .449 .363
2011 108 .207 .324 .380 .312

wOBA = Weighted On-BAse Average

Obviously, his stats are down across the board. Let’s dive into some of his peripheral numbers.

Season BB% K% ISO BABIP
2009 11.0% 16.8% .185 .327
2010 10.7% 13.6% .163 .311
2011 13.9% 21.2% .174 .231

BB% = walks/plate appearances
K% = strikeouts/plate appearances
ISO = Isolated Power
BABIP = Batting Average on Balls In Play

McCutchen is drawing more walks than usual this year, so no problem there. His Isolated Power is right in line with his career numbers. The biggest issues come from his strikeout rate and batting average on balls in play. He is striking out far more often than usual, and his batted balls are rarely dropping in for hits when he does put the ball into play. Let’s start with the low BABIP. Here is his batted ball profile, courtesy of FanGraphs.

Season LD% GB% FB% IFFB%
2009 18.6% 42.3% 39.1% 8.0%
2010 18.8% 43.4% 37.8% 10.4%
2011 15.9% 33.3% 50.7% 17.1%

LD% = Line Drives/Balls in Play
GB% = Ground Balls/Balls in Play
FB% = Fly Balls/Balls in Play
IFFB% = Infield Fly Balls/Balls in Play

He is hitting the ball in the air much more often this year, which will certainly lead to a lower BABIP. Courtesy of Baseball-Reference, here are the league-wide numbers for 2010 (infield flies included in fly balls).

BABIP
Ground Balls .234
Fly Balls .138
Line Drives .718

Due to the increased number of fly balls and pop-ups, we should not expect McCutchen’s BABIP to rise too much simply through improved luck. Using the expected BABIP calculator, we should expect McCutchen to have a BABIP of .290 this year.

Let’s move on to McCutchen’s inflated strikeout rate. The first thing I want to know is if his contact rate has dropped this season.

Season Contact Rate
2009 82.5%
2010 84.6%
2011 88.0%

McCutchen is putting the bat on the ball more frequently this year, and he is well above the league average that usually sits around 80%. That is not the problem. The problem is that he is striking out looking at a very high rate. The following numbers are courtesy of StatCorner.


Year kL% kS%
2009 3.0% 13.7%
2010 3.2% 10.4%
2011 9.3% 12.0%
MLB Average 4.5% 13.1%

kL% = Strikeouts Looking/Plate Appearances
kS% = Strikeouts Swinging/Plate Appearances

I included the major league averages, according to StatCorner. As you can see, McCutchen is going down looking far more often than usual this year. That is the biggest reason he is struggling so badly in 2011. Personally, I would be more worried if his strikeout rate was up due to swing-and-miss issues. In a one-month sample, it would only take a few borderline called third strikes to really throw off that rate.

For what it’s worth, here are the pitch locations of all called third strikes against McCutchen this season. These are from the catcher’s point of view. I included an approximate strike zone.


(click to enlarge)

Again, this is just a one-month slump that is magnified because it is occurring at the beginning of the season. It will not last all year. In fact, as I am writing this, McCutchen has homered and walked in the Pirates’ first game in Denver.

Author: Matt Bandi

Matt has covered the Pirates at Wait ‘Til Next Year, Pittsburgh Lumber Co. and now Pirates Prospects. He served as Pirates team expert for Heater Magazine in 2009 and 2010 and has contributed to Graphical Player 2009, 2010 and 2011. Matt was also the editor of the 2011 and 2012 Pirates Prospects Annuals.

Share This Post On
  • http://twitter.com/Spazaru Murray Passarieu

    I’ve always thought he was a bit overrated, plus he is clueless trying to steal bases; with his speed he should be able to. Littlefield drafted him, so I’m not all that surprised he isn’t the next Rickey Henderson!