Analyzing the Non-Tender Deadline

The Pittsburgh Pirates had a somewhat busy day today. They swapped arbitration eligible players with the Milwaukee Brewers, reached a pre-arbitration deal with Jason Grilli, non-tendered Pedro Ciriaco and Jason Jaramillo, and tendered offers to the rest of the players who were without contracts in 2012.

In the biggest move of the day, the Pirates traded Jose Veras to the Milwaukee Brewers for Casey McGehee.  I projected Veras as a non-tender candidate in my preview earlier today, noting that his $2.5 M projected salary through arbitration would be too much when you consider the strong Pirates bullpen. Milwaukee added Aramis Ramirez on a three year deal today, which made McGehee expendable.

The trade was a great move for the Pirates. They won’t miss Veras, as the current bullpen projects to have Joel Hanrahan, Evan Meek, Chris Resop, Jason Grilli, Tony Watson, Daniel McCutchen, and Chris Leroux, with Jared Hughes, Bryan Morris, Justin Wilson, Daniel Moskos, and Duke Welker serving as depth out of AAA next year. McGehee is coming off a down year, and will be arbitration eligible for the first time with a projected $3.1 M salary. He’s also a guy who is still young and has some upside.

This is a change in the normal approach for the Pirates. In the past we’ve seen them non-tender or trade guys who were reaching arbitration, even though those guys were still young enough to have an outside shot at realizing their potential. That’s not a bad move, but it was usually followed up with the signing of someone like Matt Diaz who was coming off a down year at the age of 33.  I’ll take Casey McGehee coming off a down year at the age of 29, just one season removed from hitting .285 with 23 homers and an .801 OPS, rather than taking someone like Matt Diaz and hoping the down year was just a down year, and not the beginning of the end of his career.

Neal Huntington mentioned that McGehee added a quality option for the team at both corner infield positions. He could be used in a platoon role with Garrett Jones at first base. He also provides a good backup plan to Pedro Alvarez at third base if Alvarez has another year like his 2011 season.

You could make the argument that McGehee’s 2011 season was due to bad luck. He had a .249 BABIP after a .306 BABIP in 2010 and a .330 BABIP in 2009. He had an 8.6% HR/FB ratio, after being in the 12.5-13.6% range the previous two years. Part of that down year could have been due to a thumb injury at the start of the year. McGehee hit for a .291/.346/.477 line in 965 at-bats during his first two seasons with Milwaukee. The odds of his 2011 season being legit, and his 2009-2010 numbers being a fluke seem pretty small.

If McGehee can bounce back to his 2009-2010 numbers, the Pirates will have gotten a steal. He would be good enough to start at either corner position with his 2010 numbers. He’s also under team control for three years. He’s not a guaranteed upgrade on defense at third base, although his numbers are trending in the right direction. In 2009 he had a -22.0 UZR/150. In 2010 that improved to a -4.0.  He hd a 7.3 UZR/150 in over 1200 innings during the 2011 season. By comparison, Pedro Alvarez had a -8.6 UZR/150 in 2010 and a -2.8 UZR/150 in 2011. It wouldn’t be the worst plan to put McGehee at third base and move Alvarez to first where he could focus less on defense and more on offense. For now it seems that Alvarez will start at third, with McGehee and Garrett Jones splitting time at first base.

Joel Hanrahan was one of seven arbitration eligible players who were tendered an offer of arbitration.

Contract Offers

The Pirates reached a deal with relief pitcher Jason Grilli for $1.1 M.  Grilli had a strong 2011 season with the Pirates, putting up a 2.48 ERA in 32.2 innings, along with a 37:15 K/BB ratio. He started out the year as a minor league free agent for the Phillies. He had a clause in his contract that stated the Phillies had to either add him to the 25-man roster or release him if another team wanted to add him to their 25-man roster. The Pirates called in July, and the Phillies opted to release him.

The Pirates non-tendered Pedro Ciriaco and Jason Jaramillo, making both players free agents. The team tendered offers to their remaining unsigned players, including all seven remaining arbitration eligible players. The Pirates can try to work out a deal with all seven players between now and their arbitration hearings. Players can file for arbitration between the 5th and 15th of January. The two sides then exchange contract figures on January 18th. The arbitration hearings take place between February 1st and 21st. If no pre-arbitration deal is reached, an arbiter decides which one of the two contract figures will be used for the player’s 2012 salary.

The arbitration eligible players and their projected salaries:

Joel Hanrahan – $4,000,000

Casey McGehee – $3,100,000

Jeff Karstens – $2,800,000

Garrett Jones – $2,400,000

Charlie Morton – $2,100,000

Chris Resop – $1,100,000

Evan Meek – $900,000

40-Man Roster Updates

The 40-man roster remains full after today’s moves. The 2012 40-man roster/payroll projection has been updated, and the Pirates are now projected for a payroll just over $46 M.  That payroll amount only reflects players currently on the 40-man roster, and doesn’t project any potential moves by the team in the future. The future payroll page has also been updated with the addition of Casey McGehee.

Tim Williams

Author: Tim Williams

Tim is the owner and editor in chief of Pirates Prospects. He started the site in January 2009, and turned it into his full time job during the 2011 season. Prior to starting Pirates Prospects, Tim worked with AccuScore.com, providing MLB, NHL, and NFL coverage to various national media outlets, including ESPN Insider, USA Today, Yahoo Sports, and the Wall Street Journal. He also writes the annual Prospect Guide, which is sold through the site. Tim lives in Bradenton, where he provides live coverage all year of Spring Training, mini camp, instructs, the Bradenton Marauders, and the GCL Pirates.

Share This Post On
  • http://twitter.com/steveglenn Steve Glenn

    Tim do they have the money left to offer Pena a “competitive” deal?

    • http://twitter.com/steveglenn Steve Glenn

      Forget I asked after posting our abysmal numbers against lefties below…We need D. Lee.

  • http://twitter.com/steveglenn Steve Glenn

    Two things scare me…SP (especially with Morton a big ?) and 1B.

    Against lefties last year
    Jones        .147/.279/.460
    McGehee  .169/.228/.413 (.239/.295/.689 vs Righties)
    Alvarez     .158/.289/.545

  • James S

    I wouldn’t base anything on McGehee’s aberration of a season last year. If you are are going to use numbers on McGehee, you should still use his 162 game avg at this point.
    His 2011 season was too weird. It was nothing like his previous 2 years. He had to have an injury nagging him, or just really gotten into some bad habits that any decent hitting coach could spot based on films of his previous work compared to last year.

    What guys do against lefties never worries me. As long they do good vs righties is aways my main concern because there are way more righties than lefties. It’s one of my secrets of winning fantasy leagues every year for the past 22 years.

    I’m really glad they got Grilli resigned too, he’s a good reliever.

  • Anonymous

    I could be wrong but I think McGehee played pretty well down the stretch after a worse than Pedro start to the season.

    • http://www.piratesprospects.com Tim Williams

      He had a good August, but struggled in September.