Pittsburgh Pirates 2012 25-Man Roster Projection

Pedro Alvarez has competition at third base if he struggles again this year.

Last night was the deadline for teams to tender offers to their unsigned players.  The Pittsburgh Pirates tendered offers to all of their arbitration eligible players, signed Jason Grilli to a one year deal, and traded Jose Veras to Milwaukee for Casey McGehee.  I broke down all of the moves last night after the deadline.

With the arbitration offers tendered, the projected 25-man roster is starting to take shape. It’s far from being finalized, but it’s to the point where we can upload the annual 25-man roster projection. I’ve uploaded a new page this year, which can be found here.  The page is updated with my estimated 25-man roster, based solely on the current players on the 40-man roster, plus the non-roster invitees.  Some thoughts:

-The Pirates have McGehee and Jones lined up to take first base. I’m fine with McGehee starting, since he’s only a year removed from a .285 average, 23 home run, .801 OPS season. That said, I’d like to see the Pirates try to get a better first base option. Things look much better with Jones serving as an outfielder off the bench and McGehee serving as a backup at first, second, and third, while providing insurance for Alvarez. If Alvarez goes down, you’ve got McGehee and Jones starting at the corners. That’s not ideal.

-Looking at the bench, I wouldn’t put much stock in Nick Evans making the team. He’s a popular non-roster invitee, but there doesn’t seem to be room for him with McGehee and Jones, unless the Pirates carry three first base types. There’s a bigger need for a middle infielder, unless they want to put the backup middle infield duties solely on Rule 5 pick Gustavo Nunez.

-You could make an argument that the Pirates could use another starting pitcher. Morton will miss the first month of the season, although the Pirates can get by with a spot starter until the end of April. You can’t count on Bedard for a full season. Brad Lincoln provides some immediate depth. Chris Leroux is an outside the box option for a spot starter, as he spent the off-season working on his off-speed pitches. Outside of those two the Pirates don’t have anyone who would be ready on Opening Day. Jeff Locke, Rudy Owens, Justin Wilson, and Kyle McPherson could be options at some point in 2012.

-The bullpen looks strong. The Pirates would have Jared Hughes, Daniel Moskos, Bryan Morris, and Duke Welker at the AAA level using this projection. They’ve got some strong depth, and could afford to deal someone if needed.

Share This Article

Tim Williams

Tim is the owner and editor in chief of Pirates Prospects. He started the site in January 2009, and turned it into his full time job during the 2011 season. Prior to starting Pirates Prospects, Tim worked with AccuScore.com, providing MLB, NHL, and NFL coverage to various national media outlets, including ESPN Insider, USA Today, Yahoo Sports, and the Wall Street Journal. He also writes the annual Prospect Guide, which is sold through the site. Tim lives in Bradenton, where he provides live coverage all year of Spring Training, mini camp, instructs, the Bradenton Marauders, and the GCL Pirates.

Analyzing the Non-Tender Deadline

Next Story »

Andrew McCutchen’s Extension Value

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Andrew-Smalley/100001279428589 Andrew Smalley

    Are you forgetting Navarro?  I presume he would be a better and more realistic option than Nunez.

    • http://www.piratesprospects.com Tim Williams

      My guess is they go with a Rule 5 guy and give Navarro regular playing time at AAA. But I could see either situation happening.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_67WO3TDTVV73TV6DTE64BQCGRI Dan

    With Pujos going to the Angels.. they seem too heavy at 1st base…. any rumors or thoughts on a trade with them now?

  • Anonymous

    I could really see a potential deal or 2 left trade wise. Something with Garret Jones and maybe something involving some young OFs (not Marte, starting to fall in love with him) and maybe Allie and some of the other upside prep guys. Darnaud could also be in a deal.

  • James S

    You always hope a guy like Yamaico Navarro goes into spring training and just blows away all competition for extra infielder, even at the rule 5 guy’s expense. But if they already made the investment by cutting Ciriaco and drafting the rule 5 guy, it looks like this would be the main scenario to start the season. But if Navarro just wows everyone and makes it look like they’d be nuts to go with anyone besides him, I don’t think he Pirates would mind that happening either and would return the rule 5 guy to his old team.

    I agree though that Navarro getting daily at bats and playing everyday in triple A would be the best thing for everyone right now, because the extra infielder isnt going to be used much, if you recall how Ciriaco was used.

    They know darn well that once the year starts its so hard to keep those rule 5 guys all year unless they are doing really good, which they never are. They almost always cut them loose or work out a trade to keep them and send them to the minors. (Or they get mysterious phantom injuries that keep them on the DL for a long time).

    For another starting pitcher, I have to think that they are looking closely at free agent Joe Saunders, who would be a decent addition to the staff….And what ever happened to Jeff Francis?
    I dont think I missed him signing with another team, right?

Latest Analysis

  • Coach Jeff Branson and Manager Dean Treanor before the game

    The Important Role That Indianapolis Manager Dean Treanor Plays in the Dominican

    1 day ago

    International scouting and work overseas has exploded over the past four to five years in baseball, and each organization is looking for each little advantage they can ...

    Read More
  • Photo Credit: David Hague

    The Pirates Solved Jimmy Nelson’s Curveball in the Second Matchup

    3 days ago

    Jimmy Nelson shut the Pirates down in Milwaukee on April 11th. He scattered only two hits and two walks over seven innings while striking out nine batters. ...

    Read More
  • Tyler Glasnow 7

    There Was a Different Tyler Glasnow on the Mound on Friday Night in Altoona

    3 days ago

    After Tyler Glasnow went four innings without giving up a walk last night, my initial thought was to point out how great his control looked. But then ...

    Read More
  • Photo Credit: David Hague

    Francisco Cervelli Gives His Thoughts on the “New” A.J. Burnett

    4 days ago

    For most of the second half of Spring Training, A.J. Burnett seemed to have a personal catcher in Tony Sanchez. They worked together at McKechnie Field. They ...

    Read More
  • Elias Diaz 2

    Elias Diaz’s Value Doesn’t End With His Excellent Defense and Improving Bat

    1 week ago

    While everyone knows about Elias Diaz’s throwing arm by now, the Indianapolis pitchers have been raving early in the season about the work that he puts in ...

    Read More
  • Steven Brault 5

    A Review of Steven Brault’s Sinker; Updates on Eppler, Heredia, and Holmes

    1 week ago

    There’s nothing flashy about Steven Brault. The last three times I’ve seen the left-hander, including today’s debut in Bradenton, he has been working heavily with the sinker. ...

    Read More
  • Gorkys Hernandez

    What Do the Pirates See in Gorkys Hernandez, Beyond His Outstanding Defense?

    2 weeks ago

    Gorkys Hernandez has been searching for something throughout his career that he thinks that he has finally located after a solid Spring Training: Consistency. “One thing is ...

    Read More
  • (Photo Credit: David Hague)

    This Year’s Projected Super Two Cutoff Should Have No Impact on the Pirates

    2 weeks ago

    Every year at the start of the season, an early projection for the Super Two cutoff date gets released. This year the number has been released by ...

    Read More
  • Browse More Articles

    More