Phillies Use Four-Run Inning off Cole, Mazzaro to Beat Bucs

Gerrit Cole

Gerrit Cole pitched through traffic successfully for five innings, but lost a touch after that. (Photo Credit: David Hague)

The 6th inning sunk the Pirates’ chances for another series win, as the Philadelphia Phillies collected four hits and four runs off Gerrit Cole and Vin Mazzaro to grab the Independence Day victory 6-4.

Cole entered with just 60 pitches and struck out Jimmy Rollins for the second time to start the inning. But Ryan Howard worked an 0-2 count into a walk with the help of home plate umpire Chris Conroy, then Domonic Brown singled on a three-ball count to hasten Cole’s removal from the game. Even at 78 pitches, Cole had been elevating pitches and struggling with overall command.

“When I fell behind in the count, they put good swings on the ball and just kept getting hits, whether it was a good pitch or not,” Cole said.

In came Mazzaro, the groundball pitcher the Pirates go to for drawing double-play balls. There would be no such chances as Mazzaro gave up a single to Delmon Young (Pitch 1), an RBI single to Kevin Frandsen (Pitch 2), a two-RBI single to Carlos Ruiz. After he hit next batter Cole Hamels, Mazzaro was removed with the Pirates trailing 5-1.

“Whenever you go to the bullpen and it doesn’t work, the decision was not the right one,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “If you leave the starter out there and he gives up the runs, then it wasn’t the right one.”

Jose Tabata

Jose Tabata collected two hits, including the Pirates’ only extra-base hit. (Photo Credit: David Hague)

That four-run inning was the dagger for the Pirates’ first series loss in the last month of play. Andrew McCutchen connected in his first clutch situation, ripping a two-run single in the 2nd inning to open the scoring.

His second chance came as the potential tying run after Garrett Jones’ pinch-hit RBI single made the score 6-3. McCutchen worked the count full, but grounded into a double play that scored the run but ended the rally.

Hamels performed like the Hamels of old after allowing the 2nd-inning single to McCutchen, retiring 10 straight hitters and striking out a total of eight hitters with no walks for his 3rd season win.

“His command was sharp compared to what we had seen the last few outings,” Hurdle said. “The changeup came into play very, very effectively.”

Ace In Progress

So back to Gerrit Cole, who earned his first loss after starting 4-0, before we wrap this up and go watch fireworks. He allowed only one extra-base hit, a Chase Utley double. On the other hand, he still gave up eight total hits over 5.1 innings, getting into nine 0-1 counts as opposed to 10 1-0 counts.

“Some of the angles on his breaking balls played better today,” Hurdle said. “Tried some backdoor breaking balls. Was able to figure out too when the balls around hitters’ laps, a little elevated, they were able to get some swings on it.”

What are Cole’s goals (rhyme) for next week’s start against the Oakland A’s, possibly his final one before the All-Star Break?

“I think get ahead better,” Cole said. “And just keep using the breaking balls and the changeups, and keep doing what I’ve been doing.”

Cole tied his season-high with five strikeouts and got a decent seven whiffs with mostly offspeed pitches. Check out how I tracked his pitches Wednesday. These are my personal classification based on velocity, not those from MLB or BrooksBaseball.

TYPE   SPEED     PITCHES     STRIKES     CALLED STRIKES     BALLS IN PLAY  
Fastball 92-100 43 31 10 11
Cutter/Twoseam 89-91 16 10 3 1
Changeup 85-88 12 8 1 3
Breaking Ball 80-84 7 4 0 1

So the crowd wearing red and white got to cheer more than the crowd in black and gold out of the 35,328 fans Thursday afternoon. But the Pirates take the season series from Philadelphia and retain baseball’s best record.

James Santelli

Author: James Santelli

James covers the Pirates beat for Pirates Prospects. He is a Broadcast Journalism student at USC and has written for such outlets as NBCOlympics.com, Pittsburgh Magazine and the official websites of the Los Angeles Clippers and Pittsburgh Penguins. James previously covered the Pirates for Pittsburgh Sports Report. He also broadcasts play-by-play for the USC Trojans baseball team and was awarded the 2013 Chick Hearn Memorial Scholarship and Allan Malamud Scholarship. James dispenses puns at his Twitter account (@JamesSantelli) where he promises to write in first-person. Google

Share This Post On
  • deacs

    I had my rant all ready and then I read this article. I live in Philadelphia so I don’t see any post game interviews etc. I thought the goal was to get Cole to pitch to contact and trust his defense which would allow him to keep the pitch count down and go deep into games. So naturally I got excited when I saw 45 pitches after 4 innings and I was in shock and PISSED when they took him out after 78 pitches considering the innings the bullpen has put in. But I guess if you’re elevating your pitches then maybe it’s time for the hook. I’m not going to rip the manager that has this team 20 games over. He may not be perfect but for the most part he’s pressing the right buttons.

    • emjayinTN

      deacs: Did you see those hits off of Mazzaro? A bloop by Frandsen, and a broken bat, weak hit to left – sometimes the breaks just kill a team that was otherwise deserving. It should have been 2 outs, nobody on, but the HP Umpire was giving Ryan Howard the “veteran break” on pitches that should have struck him out. That kind of crap is a learning experience for Cole, but that has a tendency to cause a young pitcher to lose a little concentration.