Below are two hits from Altoona right fielder Willy Garcia and one from catcher Elias Diaz. Garcia is the flashier of the two players and younger, but Diaz just might be the better prospect of the two players. Garcia is a toolsy outfielder, with a cannon for an arm, good speed and he can hit for power. He has the one major flaw though, that is usually a deal-breaker when it comes to Major League success, a horrible BB/K rate. Last season, he was the only Pirates minor leaguer that had 100 or more strikeouts than walks and it wasn’t even close.
Garcia is showing the same problems in AA as he did last year for Bradenton. He has 12 walks and 79 strikeouts in 233 at-bats and two of those walks were intentional. The good part is that he is young for the level, but at some point he is going to need for those numbers to go in the opposite directions. You can have all the power in the world, but if you can’t use it, it’s useless in the Majors. The pitchers are just going to get tougher the higher he goes and the scouting reports will get better going into those games. Garcia has four tools(the video below shows his speed, so don’t let the one steal this season fool you). He is just missing the hit tool and in his case, that is the most important one for his future success.
Here is a double by Garcia from Wednesday
Elias Diaz isn’t flashy like Garcia, but as I said above, he could be the better prospect. He is age-appropriate for the league, checking in at 23 years old this season. Most catchers move slower than other position players, so they tend to be a little older at each level. Last year, Diaz was at one point called the best defensive catcher in the FSL. He has thrown out 29% of runners this season which is exactly in line with his career mark. Diaz is hitting well this season, batting .303 with 10 doubles and four homers. He also makes better contact than most players, especially on a free-swinging Altoona team that I predicted before Opening Day would set the Eastern League team strikeout record and they are right on pace for that.
Diaz hit well last year for Bradenton posting a .781 OPS, though he saw limited time behind the plate. He made up for some of that time by playing in the Venezuelan Winter League this off-season and holding his own in a league filled with players with AAA/Major League experience. A strong defensive catcher that can throw, hit for average and show some patience at the plate, should get his chance in the Majors at some point and he profiles as a reliable back-up. Diaz might not flash the tools you can dream on like Garcia(mostly the power numbers), but he could very well have the better big league career when it’s all said and done with. It all depends on whether or not Garcia can change his approach at the plate as he gets older and more mature/experienced.
**I replaced the broken MiLB link for Diaz with this extended look at him on offense and defense from ROTOscouting.com