May is a Statement Month for the Pirates

If Alvarez heats up, the Pirates could put up a big month.

The Pittsburgh Pirates didn’t have the easiest schedule in the month of April.  Their opponents included the 17-9 Colorado Rockies (twice), the 18-9 Florida Marlins, and the 16-13 St. Louis Cardinals.  Combined, their opponents put up a 117-105 record, as of tonight.  Despite this, the Pirates managed a 13-15 record, heading in to tonight’s series opener with the San Diego Padres.

The impressive part was that the Pirates held their own against the winning teams.  The Cardinals, Rockies, and Marlins have combined to win 62.2% of their games this season.  They won 61.5% of their games against the Pirates, which basically puts the Pirates on par with the rest of their opponents.  The big area of success came against the two .500 teams, the Reds and the Nationals, both 14-14.  The Pirates managed a 5-2 record against these two teams.

However, the Pirates didn’t fare well against the losing teams.  The Cubs, Brewers, and Giants have combined for a 38-46 record this season, winning 45.2% of their games.  Against the Pirates, these teams won 62.5% of their games, and most of that came from the Brewers (2-0 vs the Pirates) and Giants (2-1 vs the Pirates).  That’s an area they need to improve upon, especially in the month of May.

Over the next month, the Pirates don’t play a single team that currently sports a winning record.  Four teams (Dodgers, Nationals, Reds, Braves) are currently sitting at .500.  The Pirates also have a few teams who are really struggling, including the Padres, who fell to 11-18 after tonight’s game.  Also struggling are the Astros (11-17), Tigers (12-17), Cubs (12-16), and Mets (12-16).  Those teams make up 15 of the 28 games from now until June 2nd.

The May opponents are currently combining for a 129-157 record, for a 45.1% winning percentage.  If the Pirates play at the opposite pace (54.9% winning percentage) over the next month, they will be sitting at 29-28 on June 3rd.  The last time the Pirates were at .500 that late in the season was in 2005, when they were 30-30 on June 11th.  The last time they were above .500 that late in the season was in 2004, when they were 23-22 on May 29th.

If the Pirates do end up with a 29-28 record on June 3rd, they’ll still have a long way to go, with two thirds of the season still remaining.  Being above .500 at the start of June is pretty meaningless in the grand scheme of things, although considering how bad the team was in 2010, it would be a huge step.

The month of May is a statement month for the Pirates, whether that statement is good or bad.  It’s way too early to assume the Pirates could be surprise contenders.  I wouldn’t even assume they have a strong shot at .500 this year.  However, the month of May will tell us a lot about this team.  Contenders don’t struggle against teams like the Padres, Astros, or any other team winning 45% or fewer games.  Contenders hold their own against .500 teams, and end out ahead.  Contenders also usually beat the Brewers, at least once a season.

The Pirates can make a statement in the month of May.  They can come out and steamroll the struggling opponents, while holding their own against the teams like the Reds, Dodgers, and Braves.  That wouldn’t guarantee anything, but it would show that the Pirates could be starting to turn the corner.  At the same time, if they struggle to take series victories against teams like the Padres and Astros, and get hammered by the teams close to .500, it will make the statement that the Pirates are, once again, heading for the bottom of the MLB standings.

The month of May won’t set anything in stone, but it will be a big month for the Pirates to show what kind of team they are.  Considering the strength of their upcoming schedule, it would be extremely disappointing if they were below .500 when June 3rd rolled around.

Tim started Pirates Prospects in 2009 from his home in Virginia, which was 40 minutes from where Pedro Alvarez made his pro debut in Lynchburg. That year, the Lynchburg Hillcats won the Carolina League championship, and Pirates Prospects was born from Tim's reporting along the way. The site has grown over the years to include many more writers, and Tim has gone on to become a credentialed MLB reporter, producing Pirates Prospects each year, and will publish his 11th Prospect Guide this offseason. He has also served as the Pittsburgh Pirates correspondent for Baseball America since 2019. Behind the scenes, Tim is an avid music lover, and most of the money he gets paid to run this site goes to vinyl records.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

If Cutch can pick-up his average, Pedro can find some power, and Wood can establish himself as the everyday SS, hit .250 and make the all the easy plays, I think this team will be okay.


Tim Big question here, Now we all know that Pedro struggles early in the season that goes back to his college days, but are the Pirates trying to change his swing right now and is he just adjusting? His leg kick seems shorter (which is good) but I cant tell and I didnt know if you knew if anything was going on their?


Tim ~ THE reason I am optimistic is the pitching, to date. Would you, please, investigate the number of Quality Starts by this pitching staff? I don’t recall a Bucs’ club that has consistently turned in a full month of QS. How does this compare to last season, and then when was the last time a staff performed this well in the month of April? And against quality teams as well, with only one series against each of the Cubs and Nats.

Pirates Prospects Daily



Latest articles

Latest comments