Developing Pitchers, Not Throwers

It seems like every night when I write up the daily minor league schedule I am writing about a great walk to strikeout ratio with at least one of the Pirates pitching prospects. The system is filled with guys who have a 3:1 SO/BB ratio yet the strikeout totals for the most part aren’t that great so that ratio obviously doesn’t tell the whole story. It is no secret the Pirates have their minor league pitchers work on fastball command but they also want these kids working the inside of the plate, not necessarily hitting batters but making sure they own the inside when they pitch.

Too many times over the years we have seen Pirates pitchers in the majors afraid to work inside and not attack hitters when they have two strikes, trying to get hitters to chase something outside over and over. It is obvious now that they have a plan of attack that they are teaching and it goes on from the VSL to AAA and every level in between.

Pounders has 13 hit batters, 14 walks and 63 strikeouts

The Numbers

Pirates minor league pitchers have been hitting batters at a high rate this year, which would normally signify a wild pitcher, but the walk totals seem to tell an opposite story. Here are the numbers that really stand out.

West Virginia– 1st in the SAL in hit batters with 96 and last in walks allowed with 302

Bradenton– 3rd in the FSL in hit batters with 78 (just 2 behind the leader) and last in walks allowed with 311

Altoona– Tied for 4th in the EL in hit batters and next to last in walks allowed with 344

Those three teams make up the best examples of both sides of the equation but they are also the three teams that can be considered the best teams to use for showing the teaching that is going on, because they have the most homegrown pitchers with experience in the system. Indianapolis does have the 2nd most hit batters in the IL but they also have a high walk total in part due to high totals from Brian Burres, Garrett Olson and Sean Gallagher, and not guys who were brought up through the system.

Even in the two lower levels in the states, where a lot of these kids are out of college recently, they still are being taught the philosophy of throwing inside. State College has hit 67 batters this year, 21 more than the 2nd highest total in the league. The GCL Pirates have hit 66 batters with the 2nd highest total in the league being 52. If you take it even further you will see the VSL Pirates hit the 2nd most batters.

In fact, the only team out of the eight affiliates of the Pirates that goes against this is the DSL team, who finished near the bottom in hit batters. If you read the DSL pitchers recap, you would remember that the pitching staff was filled with roster fillers due to delays in the signing of new players. It is possible they really didn’t do too much teaching with all those temporary players, instead working with kids who were at the facility training but not eligible to play.

The Individuals

If you go back to the three main teams, Altoona, Bradenton and West Virginia, you will see the results of the players learning this system. It is what I called the ABC’s of pitching (Altoona, Bradenton and Charleston,WV):

Kyle McPherson– 26 BB/134 K  5.15 K/BB ratio

Phillip Irwin– 18/92  5.11

Zack Von Rosenberg– 22/103  4.68

Brooks Pounders– 14/63  4.50

Jameson Taillon– 20/85  4.25

Eliecer Navarro– 17/71  4.18

Casey Sadler– 15/49  3.27

Brandon Cumpton– 27/88  3.26

Zac Fuesser– 27/88  3.26

Zack Dodson– 20/59  2.95

I’ll also note that 4th round pick from last year, Nick Kingham in his first full pro season, has a 12/42 ratio while the best mark at Indianapolis is Brad Lincoln 21/94 (4.48) and he obviously came up through the Pirates system.

So when you see some pitchers struggling in the lower minors for the Pirates it is important to remember they have a game plan that they plan on sticking to. These pitchers are taught to pound the inside of the plate. Sometimes it may get them in trouble with hit batters in key situations and sometimes throwing all these fastballs for strikes will get them hit hard, but it is much better for them to learn from their mistakes in the minors than it is in the majors. The Pirates are hoping that this leads to a pitching staff of pitchers and not a staff full of throwers.

John started working at Pirates Prospects in 2009, but his connection to the Pittsburgh Pirates started exactly 100 years earlier when Dots Miller debuted for the 1909 World Series champions. John was born in Kearny, NJ, two blocks from the house where Dots Miller grew up. From that hometown hero connection came a love of Pirates history, as well as the sport of baseball.

When he didn't make it as a lefty pitcher with an 80+ MPH fastball and a slider that needed work, John turned to covering the game, eventually focusing in on the prospects side, where his interest was pushed by the big league team being below .500 for so long. John has covered the minors in some form since the 2002 season, and leads the draft and international coverage on Pirates Prospects. He writes daily on Pittsburgh Baseball History, when he's not covering the entire system daily throughout the entire year on Pirates Prospects.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I agree that teaching them how to pitch and not throw in some instances could cause them to get hit hard, but as has been stated better in the minors than in the majors.
I look at this way,  they are learning how to handle adversity along with learning how to pitch. This article is why I pay very little attention to their stats.


Another very insightful article. The Pirates philosophy of pounding the zone and breaking bats seems to be the right path for these young kids. By pounding the inner half, it opens up the outer half to be vulnerable. Command of the fastball leads to getting ahead and staying ahead, and ultimately makes these prospects better pitchers. It would be easy to let these guys throw breaking balls and sliders regularly like some organizations, which would lead to much higher K/BB ratios, but also increases injuries and promotes a lack of confidence to owning the inner half. Benedict has a plan and it is good to see it taking shape throughout the organizaion.


I’ve noticed the ratios more this season and the results have been positive. However, the K rates have been low, even for Tallion. Well, not low but not dominating either. Even with his wildness, I expected Allie to rack up the Ks. But, overall keeping hitters off the bases is what it boils down to.    Good job.


One would assume that the K rates will increase once the reigns are loosened on the young pitchers and they graduate from fastball academy.

Share article

Pirates Prospects Daily

Latest articles

Pirates Prospects Weekly

MONDAY: First Pitch

TUESDAY: Article Drop


THURSDAY: Roundtable

FRIDAY: Discussion

SATURDAY: Pirates Draft Report

SUNDAY: Pirates Business

Latest comments