28.5 F
Thursday, December 1, 2022

Interview from Piratefest – Neal Huntington and Frank Coonelly

Huntington's picture from 2011 -- we didn't get a fresh one this year

As mentioned in a previous post, Pirates Prospects and some other blogs were invited backstage to interview Pirate players and front office guys.  Here’s the summary of the interviews with Neal Huntington and Frank Coonelly.  Check out the videos done by Tom Smith of Rumbunter, as well.

Frank Coonelly

  •  Charlie from Bucs Dugout asked about the draft pool amount for 2012 — Coonelly states that for the Pirates, at their position of drafting 8th overall, he anticipates a draft pool of “around $10 million”.  Coonelly also said that amount includes two compensation picks they expect to get, which is a nice indicator that the Pirates don’t expect Lee back.
  • On the draft pool changes — The Pirates had been anticipating the draft pool cap for sometime, so they planned accordingly and spent liberally knowing change was coming.
  • We asked what changes were they lobbying for in the CBA negotiations that didn’t happen — Coonelly said they wanted adjustments for market-based variances, rather than just order of finish.  For instance, just in case the LA Dodgers would tank, the Pirates wanted to ensure that they would be rated based more on their market size being bigger than smaller markets such as Pittsburgh.
  • We asked what he did like in the CBA — Coonelly said that he liked that revenue sharing disqualifiers will not go back to the large market “payors”, but rather be re-invested back to the smaller markets.  For instance, certain teams will get revenue sharing discounted as they improve over a certain period.  That lessor amount of rev sharing will be reinvested in the general pool.
  • On the changes to the International Market in the CBA — The international signing pool is capped at $2.9 million for all teams.   The changes don’t go into effect until July 2, 2012, so Coonelly immediately asked Rene Gayo if there were some players they could sign under the old rules (no cap) while they still could.  However, it doesn’t appear as if there are a lot of potential high bonus guys still out there.  Interestingly, Coonelly also mentioned that he felt there were some teams that didn’t do a lot of scouting, but rather just threw a bunch of money at players because they could.
  • We asked him about the large TV contracts recently signed by the Angels and Rangers — Coonelly stated that revenue sharing orginally started to compensate for the disparity of TV contracts at that time.  He cited that the Yankees signed a contract at the time for $40 million a year, which is now chicken feed compared to the $150 million per year the Angels recently signed.  However, the Angels don’t get the full whack of that $150 million as some of it goes back to the revenue sharing pool occupied in part by the Pirates.
  • We asked him if there was additional corporate sponsorship interest as a result of the positive vibes from the 2011 season — Coonelly stated that there was additional interest in the team, but historically the Pirates have done well with sponsorships because they draw more people (1.9 million last year) than any other potential recreation event.  The Pirates are also considered a very family-friendly entity, which helps people want to associate themselves with the Pirates.
  • On the Pirates pulling out of the Venezuelan Summer League — The Pirates built the new Dominican facility with the expectation to hold 2 teams at some point, because they anticipated the political instability of Venezuela.
  • We asked about the potential of raising the minor league salaries — The Pirates are strong proponents of petitioning MLB to raise the minor league salaries and per diems for the players so that they can eat better food and have more normal budgets.
  • And finally we asked the elephant in the room question about payroll — Coonelly stated that Opening Day payroll will be “higher than at the end of the season, with flexible room in the budget to add a piece if needed”.  So that would put the payroll somewhere around $55 million POTENTIALLY.  The Pirates aren’t just going to spend money to meet some artificial number by Opening Day.

Neal Huntington

  • On first base options — Huntington said that right now it will be Jones and McGehee in a platoon at 1B, with players like Hague/Fox/Evans in the mix, as well.  They are comfortable with breaking camp, if necessary, with those players.
  • We asked him about what Larry Broadway did to warrant the perceived large jump from area scout to farm director (replacing the promoted Kyle Stark) — Revealingly, Huntington said that they signed Broadway as a minor league free agent player “with the intent on grooming him into a front office type of guy”.  He will rely heavily on Stark for the first year, but will transition fully over the course of the year.
  • We asked him what he, specifically, had learned and changed over the course of his tenure — Huntington was quite honest in his answers here.  First he said “I made a mistake bringing James McDonald back so quickly from his oblique injury at the start of 2011.”  Second, he said that he now values intangibles in a player more than he did coming from a strict talent evalutator standpoint.  He also admitted that he overvalued the importance of a role player’s presence in the clubhouse, specifically saying that Matt Diaz set the tone for the team in Spring Training and April, but couldn’t keep it up throughout the season because he wasn’t a starter.
  • On upside moves — Huntington mentioned that he has also changed his mindset about just going with safe players, realizing that they should gamble a little bit.  Example one — Erik Bedard.  Great upside if he can stay healthy.
  • On the recently acquired Yamaico Navarro — The Pirates have made it known that they are open to trading prospects, not just collecting them anymore.  Navarro’s presence may be downplayed now that McGehee was acquired shortly after him.  It sounds like between McGehee and the Rule 5 pickup Nunez that Navarro may be in AAA.
  • On the Rule 5 draft — Huntington flat-out stated that he’s not a fan of the Rule 5 draft, even though they’ve taken a player each year he’s been here.  If the new CBA proposed eliminating it, he would have been the first person to stand up and applaud the decision.  He feels it stunts development and also hurts the player’s mentality that teams are giving up on him.
  • We asked about Darvish and Chen — Huntington stated that we were the first people to ask if they even bid on Darvish (they didn’t).  He also stated that Chen is a free agent pitcher they are considering.

Thanks again to Brian Warecki from the Pirates and Tom Smith from Rumbunter for organizing this event again.


+ posts


Pirates Prospects has been independently owned and operated since 2009, entirely due to the support of our readers. The site is now completely free, funded entirely by user support. By supporting the site, you are supporting independent writers, one of the best Pittsburgh Pirates communities online, and our mission for the most complete Pirates coverage available.

Related articles

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Michael M. Bierce

If any of you believe the Pirates will turn things around and once again become a contender, you have indeed drank too much of the Kool-Aid that that Three Stooges serve to the mistaken masses of Pirate fans.  This team will lose at least another 90 games this year, with no end in sight at all.

Unless Nutting sells the team to an owner who wants to win… who puts winning over profits and has the money to spend, look for another 20 years of consecutive below .500 ball.


The Bucs certainly have to do something to improve for 2012. The current roster is not going to come close to finishing over 500 unless everything breaks the team’s way.

Today’s paper reported that ticket sales have gone up, so the only reason not to bring in more talent is that NH can’t find a trading partner that is a good match.  Seems to me that there should be chips available that would not impact the long term future of team.  I would rather deal Pressley than Marte but think Marte has more value.  So I am willing to part with Marte if there is a good return.  I wonder if the Bucs talked to Endy Chavez?  He signed for McLouth money and is more of a sure thing as 4th outfielder.


In a conversation with NH &FC,Charlie W. said they mentioned they had or are pursuing a trade with Seattle for Smoak or Carp and with the Mets for Lucas Duda(who I really like). Anymore on these comments?  Also do you see us looking for another SP?


At the interview session that these notes cover, Charlie and Vlad were present from BD.  Smoak, Carp, and Duda were not brought up.  Ike Davis was brought up and NH didn’t want to talk about a player under contract, but mentioned that a player with his # of years of control would cost a bit in prospects.

If Charlie mentioned those other guys, it may have been in a side conversation.

And yes…I do see the Pirates going for another SP.


actually, I was in fact the one that made the Fan Post on Bucs Dugout about the potential acquisitions of either Smoak, Carp, or Duda. I had a one-on-one talk with Huntington during Piratefest on Saturday and he specifically told me that he was been in contact with the Mets and Mariners on acquiring one of those three (he specifically mentioned Smoak, Carp, and Duda to me). also, he mentioned that he still has not ruled out acquiring one of the three via trade and is still having discussions with the Mets and Mariners. I also asked him about a possibility of bringing in Joe Saunders with him not being tendered by the DBacks in the aftermath of the DBacks getting Cahill. he said to me that right now he views Saunders and Bedard as the same type of pitcher and them getting Bedard for cheaper than what Saunders


What about maybe pushing for a deal for Rizzo, SD.  With him being blocked by the Latos deal.  Would not mind Alonso either.  Blanks has awsome power also, something that is in short supply with the Buc’s….

James Vargo

I still don’t get the Doumit thing. He was a good bat this year, when healthy. But the awful defense and the McHenry thing make even Jaramillo a better option at catcher. Barajas is a better option than this years catching situation. Barajas>2011Catchers

And yes, yearly I drink the Kool-Aid.

Brian Bernard

Konerko is a poor fielder and and aging bat… no thanks.


Yeah Brian.  He sure showed it last season.  .300 avg, 31 hrs, 105 rbi, and .388 obp.  We sure cant have that in the burg with a less then stellar fielder like Jones at 1b.  Come one man.  He would be a HUGH upgrade of G.I Jones and you know it.  Plus, he had a .994 fielding percentage and 7 errors while Jones had a .989 and 12 errors.


A lot of $ for Konerko for just this year or next. If I’m trading with CWS I want Alexei Ramirez bad. Barmes fits in perfect as a super utility and I’m pretty sure Ramirez is under contract for at least next 3 seasons


I have a suggestion for a trade value comparison.  How about Paul Konerko?  It looks like Chicago is selling off for the future and due to that fact of his age and salary, he is someone the Bucs should look into IMHO.  What do you think?

Alan Tormey

Well, Jones/McGehee seems to be the best we can do right now, which doesn’t mean that things can’t change.  I, for one, don’t think it’s that bad.  Both of those players had underperforming years and I think it’s likely that one of them could break out in a big way.  By fostering a little competition between them, rather than just having a straight left/right platoon like w/ Diaz might put a fire under one or both of them.  Also, by talking about McGehee as first base material, it helps to take some pressure off Pedro and, hopefully, will help him just relax so he can get back into his groove.

Nick Campano

If Neal is truly comfortable with Jones/McGehee platoon at 1B he is nuts and this is very disappointing as a Buccos fan!  Really not sure team has improved all that much yet this off-season.  Neal and Frank need to stop talking and start delivering on promise to make the team better at the major league level.  If pitching slides this season (as most expect), this team is going to push 90 losses again!  Sad.

white angus

barajaseveryone else who played the corners

yes, we need a full time1Bman.  but we certainly are better than the start of 2011

Share article

Latest articles


Latest comments