Pittsburgh Pirates Season Recap: Second Base

Neil Walker was the steady glove at second base for the majority of the season. He appeared in 101 of the first 103 games over the first four months before an injury forced Walker to end his 2012 season early. Walker was diagnosed with a herniated disc in his low back, which forced his to miss 16 straight games from August 27th-September 4th. Manager Clint Hurdle called upon rookie Brock Holt, who filled the void primarily in his absence during that stretch.

Overall, Walker missed 27 of the final 35 games attempting to battle through the injury while several players got looks at the position. Walker will be arbitration eligible this season, and there has been no current updates on a long-term contract extension as of the end of the season.


Neil Walker

Walker was in midst of putting together a career-year before the back injury forced him to put away his cleats early. Walker hit just .200 over his final 10 games attempting to battle through the herniated disc, but felt the best thing for both him and the team was to end his season early. Walker finished with a  .280 average with 27 doubles, 14 home runs and 69 RBI in 129 games with the Pirates. His 14 long balls surpassed his career-high 12 that he hit in 2011. They are the most by a Pirates second baseman since Warren Morris in 1999 (15).


Brock Holt

Holt started the season at Double-A Altoona, but the infielder’s bat got him not only to a promotion to Triple-A, but to the Majors as well. Holt was one of the first round of September callups, and Manager Clint Hurdle inserted Holt into the starting lineup as the team’s second baseman for 11 straight starts in Walker’s absence. Holt hit .292 with two doubles, a triple and three RBI in 24 games with the Pirates. Combined at Double-A and Triple-A, Holt hit .344 with 31 doubles, 6 triples, three home runs,  50 RBI and 16 stolen bases in 126 minor league games.

Holt will likely start the 2013 back in Triple-A to get more at-bats with Indy. He appeared in just 24 games at that level before becoming a September callup.


Josh Harrison

Harrison broke camp with the Pirates out of spring training for the first time in his career and spent the entire season in Pittsburgh as the club’s super utility man. Harrison hit for a .233 clip with nine doubles, five triples, three homers and 16 RBI in 104 games with Pirates. He bounced around for the club and provided a spark in the lineup. He made 18 starts at shortstop, 18 at second base, 10 in right field and nine at third base. Harrison will likely fill the same role with the Pirates in 2013.


Chase d’Arnaud

After making his Major League debut in June of last season and going on to appear in 48 games with Pittsburgh, d’Arnaud spent the majority of the 2012 season in Triple-A Indianapolis. d’Arnaud hit .252 (96-for-381) with 24 doubles, four triples, six homers and 38 RBI in 98 games with Indy. The infielder swiped 34 bases out of 39 attempts, which was ranked second in the International League.

D’Arnaud’s playing time after being promoted in September was limited. He went 0-for-6 with two runs scored in eight games with the Pirates and made just one start at second base on October 1st.


Jordy Mercer

Mercer appeared in 56 games at Triple-A Indianapolis to start the 2012 season before the Pirates promoted the infielder to the big leagues. In limited playing time, Mercer hit .210 with five doubles, a triple, homer and five RBI in 42 games with the Pirates. He made 28 appearances (nine starts) at shortstop and seven appearances (four starts) at second base.

Mercer batted .287 with Triple-A and was with the Pirates from July 6 through end of season. Mercer will likely head into spring training battling for a bench role with the club. With Clint Barmes’ final year of his contract in 2013, Mercer could get more looks next year to see if he has the bat for an everyday player in the future.



by Tim Williams

Neil Walker is under team control for four more years, so there’s not much of a need for prospects at this position in the short-term. The Pirates do have a few options, with Brock Holt currently leading the upper level choices. Holt could see some playing time next year if Walker misses more time with injuries, and that’s always a possibility of happening with a back injury. Ultimately Holt profiles more as a utility player, with the chance to be a starter if he can continue hitting for a high average in the majors. He doesn’t hit for much power, so his value is going to have to come from his average and on-base skills. His .682 OPS this year wouldn’t be enough as a starter.

Josh Harrison, Chase d’Arnaud, and Jordy Mercer are all in a similar situation as Holt. None of them have put up impressive offensive numbers in their limited time in the majors so far. They are all getting up there in age, to the point where they’re looking more like utility players than potential starting options.

The Pirates have an interesting option in Double-A with Adalberto Santos. He was drafted as a second baseman and played 26 games at the position in 2011. He didn’t get any time at the position in Altoona this year, although he played second last night in the AFL. Santos hit for a .340 average with a .425 OBP. He’s similar offensively to Brock Holt in that he doesn’t hit for much power, but hits for average and gets on base at a good rate. He’s also not good defensively, so he’d have to continue with a high average/OBP in order to be more than a future utility player.

The top second base prospect in the system might be Dilson Herrera. Right now he hasn’t played above short-season A-ball, spending a few weeks at the level at the end of the year. Herrera is a great hitter with plus speed and pop in his bat. He’s got the chance to be next year’s Alen Hanson. Herrera is a long way from the majors, and because of that he’s no guarantee. But with Walker under control for four more years, the Pirates have plenty of time to develop the young infielder, just in time to take over in the majors when Walker is set to leave after the 2016 season.

Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Negative Nancy’s. I’m pretty sure Brock Holt showed he can hit and hit well, and I was happy to see his defense look good as well although not elite. Good impressive player. I’m a back surgery vet and although it greatly improved my daily life, I’ve not felt like I was back to fully healthy. I’m also not a professional athlete with professional physical therapists either though. I wish him the best and have my fingers crossed for a full recovery.


I’ll beg to differ with anyone says the Pirates don’t have any talent in the scouting dept…….beause they sure have a talent for drafting players who can’t hit or field.

John Lease

And profile as utility players, at best.


I really started to get into the Pirates when Nutting took over and declared that they were going to build thru the draft.
They built the academy in the DR and spent money in the draft and I thought……WOW! This front office is Really Serious about what they are doing and I argued on many web sites against people who may or may not have an agenda against Nutting that this team is moving forward with NH leading the way.
After watching Huntington go head to head with Scott Boros and losing their 1st rd pick last year I started to wonder what the hell Huntington was trying to prove ? I really think this guy is an ego maniac that is out to prove that he is smarter than everybody else in baseball. That is why he came up with the idea to draft Sanchez and a bunch of high school pitchers, spending millions and accomplishing NOTHING….!
This team is still years and years away from the only thing I wanted and that is for the …..PITTSBURGH PIRATES… to be a team that is respected in the baseball world….. I don’t expect the Pirates to go head to head with the Yankees and other big market teams every year but at least to gain respect as the Rays have done and the only way to do that is to have a leadership that understands where they are and leave their egos at the door.
Mr. Nutting open your eyes.


 Wait,you mean every player we have drafted hasn’t turned into a everyday MLB starter or quality SP, shocker!

This is how draft and develop works, if you get one quality regular per draft you are doing well.


I don’t mind if you disagree with me but please don’t ascribe to me statements that I didn’t make.

John Lease

Piratemike, many here find only unstinting praise for the front office to be the only answer. For the amount of money Huntington poured into the draft, there has been very little return so far. Unless you can get excited about guys in A ball.

Comments are closed.

Most Voted Comments