The Pittsburgh Pirates didn’t have a catching prospect in MLB.com’s top 10 list that was released today, but Jonathan Mayo released the 11-15 rankings and had Wyatt Mathisen on the list. I’m not sure if the players were listed in order of their ranking, but Mathisen was the fourth one down.

The Pirates drafted Mathisen in the second round of the 2012 draft. He was ranked as the top prep catcher in the draft, although he didn’t spend a lot of time catching in high school. He was so athletic that his coach used him as a shortstop, and rarely had him behind the plate. He spent a lot of time working on his catching with Tom Prince and Milver Reyes in the GCL after signing with the Pirates. He’s got the potential to be a two-way catching prospect, although he’s no guarantee to stick behind the plate. That doesn’t have much to do with his skills. It’s just not automatic for prep catchers to remain catchers all the way through the minors, no matter how athletic they are (SEE: Walker, Neil).

We had Mathisen ranked as the 16th best prospect in the system.

IMPORTANT: You will need to update your password after the switch to the new server in order to log in and comment. Go to the Password Reset Page to change your password.

4 COMMENTS

  1. Also noticed that Mike Rosenbaum at Bleacher Report (I know, I know……) ranked the Pirates overall farm system as #1 the other day.

    His next 5 were Cards, D’Backs, Mariners, Marlins and Rangers, FWIW.

  2. So Wyatt has passed Tony Sanchez in terms of prospect value? There’s really not a lot of love for Tony, is there?

    • It’s just because Tony’s big league ready. He doesn’t have that new car smell anymore. He has that…well, he can be a good hitter sometimes, and he has a good arm, but he likes to run his mouth on twitter and get into bar fights, kind of thing going on. lol.

      I don’t think he’ll be a player that everyone will necessarily be proud to call their 4th overall pick from that draft, but considering reality and the general attrition rate, I think he has the ability to be quite serviceable as a major leaguer; the kind of guy you need on a team to bring the average play of the team up a notch. You have to blame the Pirates due to their lack of success over the last two decades for the fans expecting every hitter come up and hit .300 w/30 HRs. That’s just not the kind of offensive production you can simply come to expect with every player. What he does offer is being a potentially acceptable-average hitting catcher with plus defensive capabilities.

Comments are closed.