Minor League Ball put out their second mock draft yesterday and they added a new name to the mix for the Pittsburgh Pirates, High School catcher Nick Ciuffo.  The backstop from South Carolina was called possibly the best all around catcher in this draft class. Matt Garrioch, who posted the mock draft, thinks he could get to the majors faster than any other catcher in the draft class. 2013 draft

Most of this year, Reese McGuire has been called the best catcher in this class, a few giving that title to Jon Denney from Oklahoma. Along with Ciuffo, all three are HS catchers. Garrioch has McGuire going #12 in the draft, Ciuffo #14 and Denney going 26th overall.

With the #9 pick, Garrioch has the Pirates taking Arkansas pitcher Ryne Stanek. That seems like a possible pick and is close to where we have heard Stanek going recently, after starting the year as a possible #1 overall pick.

If the draft went down the way they predict, the Pirates would be passing over McGuire, Austin Meadows and Clint Frazier with that ninth pick. Both Meadows and Frazier have been top six picks all year, anywhere in the 1-6 spots until recently. The two High School outfielders from the same town in Georgia, both have huge upside and plenty of tools. Oddly, both have fallen at the same rate, keeping their names together all season long.

Another player between the 9 and 14 picks on that list, is JP Crawford, a toolsy HS shortstop, who looks like he can stick at the position and hit at the top of the order.

Right after the #14 pick is Dominic Smith, a power hitting High School first baseman from California. That #15 spot is where he is mentioned in most drafts.

One big surprise from this mock draft is Trey Ball lasting until the 19th pick. That would be shocking because he has been going higher in every other mock draft and he has also been linked to the Pirates. The 6’6″ lefty out of New Castle HS in Indiana, throws low 90’s, with an excellent change-up. He is also very athletic, good enough to be drafted early as an outfielder.

IMPORTANT: You will need to update your password after the switch to the new server in order to log in and comment. Go to the Password Reset Page to change your password.

3 COMMENTS

  1. WADR, I have not heard a whole lot about Matt Garrioch and his ability to predict. It sounds like an attempt to get ink by running contrary to just about every other prediction service I have read. Trey Ball at #19 – the Cardinals are definitely hoping that scenario will play out. The truth is that this draft is thin at the top, but goes further with very talented players. It depends upon the needs of the ball club and he thinks the Pirates need another Catcher. I do not.

    • He has been doing a lot of draft coverage from the beginning and if John Sickels trusts him enough to post a mock draft, that is good enough for me. For actual articles on mock drafts, we try to stick to the more well-known people. For lesser known(doesn’t mean they are better or worse), I put them in the notes of the draft prospect watch

Comments are closed.