The Pirates had a great draft, and it wasn't just because of first round picks like Reese McGuire.
The Pirates had a great draft, and it wasn’t just because of first round picks like Reese McGuire.

Last week Baseball America released their draft ratings, and graded the Pirates 2013 draft as the best in baseball. Yesterday they released their Pirates draft report card, looking at the best players from this specific draft. I’ll let you check out the link above for the individual reports. Below is the rundown of each player, with some thoughts below.

Best Pure Hitter: Austin Meadows (1st round)

Best Power Hitter: JaCoby Jones (3rd round)

Fastest Runner: Jones/Meadows/Jeff Roy (19th round)

Best Defensive Player: Reese McGuire (1st round)

Best Fastball: Buddy Borden (7th round)

Best Secondary Pitch: Cody Dickson (4th round)

Best Pro Debut: Austin Meadows (GCL), Adam Frazier (5th round, Jamestown)

Best Athlete: JaCoby Jones

Most Intriguing Background: Erich Weiss (11th round)

Closest to the Majors: Austin Meadows/Adam Frazier

Best Late Round Pick: Billy Roth (16th round)

The One That Got Away: Bryan Baker (40th round)

They also noted that several pitchers were topping out at 95-96, including Chad Kuhl (9th round), Justin Topa (17), Brett McKinney (19), and Henry Hirsch (22).

The Pirates draft was probably graded so high due to the multiple picks in the top half of the first round. But the draft looks really strong after the first round. The Pirates went for upside players, and didn’t really waste picks on true organizational guys. A lot of guys in the top ten rounds are risky, but have a serious chance of making it to the majors and being more than just bullpen/bench options. The guys in the later rounds aren’t just roster fillers, but are guys with at least one good tool. There’s the previously mentioned pitchers with strong velocity, or guys like Jeff Roy with a ton of speed, or some of the players who weren’t mentioned here, like Danny Collins, who has some power potential.

It’s been popular to say that this draft could be the best one the Pirates have had. Right now it would be tough to top the 2011 draft. That group has Gerrit Cole, Tyler Glasnow, Josh Bell, Clay Holmes, and other prospects who are either showing promise, or still young enough to break out like Jason Creasy and Jake Burnette. But I think the 2013 class has a shot to be just as good. The 2011 draft looks like it could have two top of the rotation starters, plus an impact hitter and a middle of the rotation starter. That’s a tough class to beat, but with all of the upside in 2013, plus the two first round picks, it definitely makes it possible.

It’s also good to see that the Pirates can get so many promising guys in the middle and late rounds, since they will be picking later in the first round and won’t have guys like Meadows and McGuire available going forward. These opinions are all first impressions, and can change down the line. The true measure of a draft is how many major league players come from that group. We won’t know that for a few years, but right now all signs point to the 2013 draft as an early success.

IMPORTANT: You will need to update your password after the switch to the new server in order to log in and comment. Go to the Password Reset Page to change your password.


  1. We’re gonna need drafts like 2011 to keep pace with the Cards. I hope this one beats or exceeds it.

    As Leadoff suggests, however, we’re gonna have to prove we can draft like the Cards, who seem to excel, even when picking low.

  2. Meadows being closest to the majors was the one that stood out to me. I mean I guess they project 6 or 7 guys to make the majors probably and then pick one from there, but still, seeing a toolsy HS OF there is pretty surprising.

  3. Great report, IMO, Pirate fans should be worried about how the Pirates will draft when they no longer have the Coles and Alvarez’s to pick from, I personally only concentrated on a couple of their top picks in the 2011 or 2013 drafts, it is good to know that they have drafted a lot of talent in those two rounds, it seems to me that they are drafting better as time goes on with this administration. I was afraid we were going to see Brooks Pounder drafts with the 2nd pick, which now will be the first picks in future drafts.

  4. Interesting to see Meadows listed as “closest to majors.” Tim, what are the best case and most realistic projections of when he gets to Pittsburgh?

    • I could see him on the following path, best case:

      2014: West Virginia
      2015: Bradenton/Altoona
      2016: Indianapolis/Majors

      Of course, if they have McCutchen/Marte/Polanco in the majors, they could take their time with Meadows. He doesn’t have to be added to the 40-man until after the 2017 season. If they wanted to go a level a year, it would put him in the majors in 2018. That’s right around the time that McCutchen’s deal runs out. It also brings Meadows up at the age of 23, giving the Pirates control through his age 29-30 seasons. That might not be a bad approach, assuming McCutchen will probably get a monster deal that the Pirates couldn’t match.

Comments are closed.