Josh Bell could crack a top 100 prospect list next year.
Josh Bell could crack a top 100 prospect list next year.

The Pittsburgh Pirates have a lot of top prospects in their system. Jameson Taillon and Gregory Polanco have emerged as consensus top 25 prospects in baseball. Alen Hanson and Tyler Glasnow are both getting attention as top 50 prospects. Austin Meadows and Reese McGuire will most likely crack a lot of top 100 lists next year. Nick Kingham could also challenge for the back end of a few top 100 lists, while Luis Heredia has been on some lists before, and could remain depending on how people see his upside.

One player who has been overlooked has been Josh Bell. The outfielder was considered a top 100 prospect prior to the 2012 season, but missed most of the year with a knee injury. Bell could be back on at least one top 100 list, as Jim Callis says that he is close to the top 100 list for 2014.

Callis notes that Bell has been passed up and overshadowed the last two years. He points out that Gregory Polanco and Alen Hanson passed him with breakout years in 2012, followed by Tyler Glasnow and Stetson Allie making a lot of noise in 2013. Bell had a good season in 2013, with a .279/.353/.453 line, 37 doubles, and 13 homers. That’s what you would have wanted out of him when drafted, although the mega numbers by Allie overshadowed everyone at the level.

One thing that Callis points out is that scouts have said Bell is too upright from the right side of the plate. John Dreker mentioned several times on this site that scouts had issues with Bell’s swing from the right side. However, he did hit for a .302/.353/.491 line against left-handers.

At one time, Josh Bell was penciled in to future lineups in Pittsburgh. Now he’s kind of an afterthought with the emergence of Gregory Polanco, and Starling Marte settling in to the majors. If he continues to develop well, he could still be in the plans, possibly as a long-term first base option. He could also emerge as trade bait if the Pirates have a full outfield (AKA, if Polanco makes the successful jump to the majors) and they find another option for first. Either way, he’s still a top prospect, but the Pirates situation has gotten to the point where he’s more of a bonus than the necessity he was in 2011.

IMPORTANT: You will need to update your password after the switch to the new server in order to log in and comment. Go to the Password Reset Page to change your password.


  1. Bell is in the minors for a reason, he only had one full year of minor league ball, this guy is an elite talent and should not be overlooked. I rated his talent level above Polanco and I rate Polanco very high. I would like to see them move him to 1st base because Meadows is coming and I believe Meadows will move through the system faster than Bell. Meadows should be ready to take Cutch’s place in the outfield when Cutch moves on in a few years.

  2. Eventually Bell may move to 1B. But if and only if three things happen this season does it make sense.

    First is Polanco playing well enough in AAA then hopefully Pittsburgh to make the MLB outfield set through2018.

    Second is Meadows and Ramirez playing well at WV making them better prospects than Bell for the OF.

    Last is the Pirates not finding a long term answer at 1B via development of Lambo or Dickerson or in a trade for a young controllable guy.

    If we are sitting here next October and all of this has happened I say send Bell to a winter league and teach him 1B.

  3. These “top whatever” prospects lists vary so much, its hard to really take them too seriously. Bell is an example. Shockingly, he was not even rated in the top 20 in the SAL, but he may be in the top 100 overall??

Comments are closed.