BRADENTON, Fla. – After seeing a breakout campaign in West Virginia the first two months of the season, the Pirates decided to promote outfielder Tito Polo to Bradenton for the second half of the season. Polo entered the 2015 season with a lot of promise, due to his five tool upside. However, he struggled with a .641 OPS at West Virginia on the year. This time around, he saw big improvements, putting up a .919 OPS in 225 at-bats with West Virginia before the promotion.

“[He’s a] difference maker on the bases,” Bradenton Manager Michael Ryan said. “I think he had 20-something bags already. [12] homers. So a combination of power and speed. Try to get him to utilize that each night. Very good defensive center fielder.”

Polo finished his first half with West Virginia by putting up 12 home runs and 20 stolen bases in those 225 at-bats. He also had 14 doubles and three triples. And now he will get a chance to show what he can do in Bradenton.

“I was excited, because I worked hard everyday,” Polo said of the promotion.

The biggest changes this year are his work on recognizing and hitting the curveball. He didn’t have a bad strikeout rate last year, at 18.6%, which was almost identical to his 18.7% rate this year. But he was making better contact on breaking stuff this time around, resulting in a big increase in power.

“Now it’s better,” Polo said on his approach against a breaking pitch. “I feel good now. I see more, I just stay back a lot. That’s the big change from last year to this year.”

There are still some things to work on. Ryan said that Polo needs work on cleaning up his decisions when to run, when not to run, where to throw the ball from the outfield, and still needs continued work on his breaking ball recognition. He’s going to see better quality breaking stuff at the new level, which should pose a new challenge.

So far, Polo has struggled at the new level, although it’s only been 18 plate appearances, and the tools still show up on the field. He will be a guy to watch the rest of the season, as he’s a five tool player who could reach the big leagues as a starter. He’s also Rule 5 eligible this off-season, so the Pirates will have to see a lot in the second half in order to make a decision on his future.

Brubaker Still Dealing With Command Issues

JT Brubaker was also promoted to Bradenton last month, and has made three starts so far, with some early struggles at the new level. The right-handed starter has given up 11 runs on 17 hits in 15.1 innings, with 11 strikeouts and 6 walks. I got a chance to see his best outing at the level, where he threw six innings, giving up just two runs, and walking two batters. However, even in that outing, he ran into some command issues.

“Hitters are a little different here than Low-A,” Brubaker said. “A little bit more of an approach. Pitch selection and what you’ve got to throw in situations might be a little bit different.”

When his command was off, Brubaker said he was getting out in front of the ball, and leaving it up a bit, due to his arm falling behind. This puts his fastball command off, which affects his secondary stuff.

This was a problem for Brubaker in West Virginia. He was giving up a lot of walks, and was getting hit pretty hard at times — more than a guy should who is pitching 90-93 MPH, with a strikeout slider and the ability to throw a changeup. He settled down his last three outings, giving up two runs in 18 innings, with a 27:4 K/BB ratio.

“I was just making sure I was getting the ball down in the zone, which allowed the off-speed to play on it,” Brubaker said of that late success. “When you’re throwing the ball up, and then trying to throw off-speed down in the zone, it’s easy takes for the hitters. You’ve got to be able to get ahead with the fastball, and then let the off-speed play. If you get behind early, it’s easy takes for the off-speed, and you get in hitter’s counts, and you have to make certain pitches. That leads to walks and hits and big innings.”

So far, the problems shown by Brubaker in his early starts in Bradenton are a repeat of his problems earlier in West Virginia. If he does get his fastball command down again, then he’s got some good secondary stuff that can work off that primary pitch.

“The slider has always been there,” Brubaker said. “It’s just making sure I get ahead. I think that was the big thing. Changeup, I still have trust in it, but it can always get better. It always goes back to getting ahead early in counts, and not being in hitter counts.”

Brubaker is a tall, projectable pitcher at 6′ 4″, 175 pounds, and already sits comfortably in the low 90s. He’s got the potential for a nice three pitch mix. However, he will need to keep the fastball down in the zone more often in order to realize his upside as a potential starter in the big leagues.

IMPORTANT: You will need to update your password after the switch to the new server in order to log in and comment. Go to the Password Reset Page to change your password.


      • Are the Pirates in on any of top 30 or even top 50 prospects? To use an NFL draft analogy, the Pirates seem to prefer to get 10 7th round picks instead of 2 first round picks…quantity over quality. Maybe that is why our DSL team is so bad?

        • Right, and the W-L record of our DSL team affects the ML standings how? The low minors are all about projection and unless you see the players and know what you are looking at, there’s no way to know until a few years have passed. Tito Polo is a prime example, you were probably bitching about his .6something OPS last year.

          Polanco and Marte weren’t top 50 IFA prospects, how did they turn out? You are assuming that 17 year old top prospects automatically turn out to be stars like NFL top picks, but it doesn’t work that way very often in baseball. In the 40+ years of the MLB FA draft, only two #1 overall picks have been elected to the HOF. And MLB teams have much better reads on the FA draft prospects than on IFA’s.

    • Here’s what JD wrote this morn when I wondered if we should be doing what the Braves, Pads and Nats are doing:

      I don’t believe a high bonus guarantees anything and history has shown that to be true.

      I also don’t believe it’s wise to pay 100% tax on so many players, basically doubling the cost of someone who is already a huge longshot of becoming anything.

      I also don’t believe it’s wise to essentially give up signing any quality players for the next two years because you have zero idea what will be available during those two years.

      You’re basically taking huge gambles for a lot of extra money and then assuming you didn’t want anything of quality the next two years. The other part is you’re doing this for international players who are 5-6 years away from the majors even if they do make it.

  1. The Pirates have quite a number of very good prospects in AAA and AA this season, but is anyone else concerned that there doesn’t seem that much behind them in the lower levels – especially position players.
    What position player in the Pirates organization, starting with High A and down through the Low A level, short-season, and rookie levels appear to be top prospects, as was the case when Polanco, Hansen, Marte, Meadows, etc. were at those levels? I can’t think of one, and that includes our #1 pick this past draft. I know they have some players with potential, but none that have potential and are also producing at their current level. Polo is probably the closest we have to such a player, but he is really struggling in High A so far. Did I overlook anyone?

    • Ke’Bryan Hayes, Cole Tucker, Will Craig, and Tito Polo are the big ones. Polo is only struggling in 18 plate appearances. If he goes 3-for-4 tonight, suddenly he’s no longer struggling.

      • I like Yeudy Garcia and Stephen Tarpley from the Bradenton staff, and Tucker, Kramer, and Luplow from the hitters as guys I will see in Pittsburgh some day.

        From the Power, I love Keller, like Hinsz and Sendelbach on the pitching side and and looking forward to seeing Jacob Taylor back on the bump soon. Besides Hayes, I like Tolman as a guy who could end up on the ML roster.

        And think about this – did you think Adam Frazier was a prospect a couple of years ago? How about Elias Diaz in 2012? Or Edwin Espinal at the end of April this year?

        • Also, I didn’t see the rest of your response earlier about Frazier, Diaz, and Espinal. But if you’re asking me specifically, then yes.

          In 2014, I had to explain that JaCoby Jones (tearing it up in WV) wasn’t getting promoted to Bradenton in part because Frazier was blocking him (pointing out his skills were better than the results).

          Diaz has looked good in batting practice and has shown a lot of tools for years, which we’ve noted. So we were expecting that 2015 breakout to be a possibility.

          We had Espinal as a lottery ticket, and explained him as one of the reasons Jose Osuna had to move to the outfield to continue getting playing time.

          All of those are examples why you rely more on live reports than stats in the lower levels.

  2. I am not sure who the Pirates have in this position. But I would love to see Omar Moreno as the roving outfield/base running coach.

Comments are closed.