Unlike the Pitcher of the Month award where Trevor Williams was the only choice, the hitters group had a few choices to discuss. Logan Hill had a slightly higher OPS than Barrett Barnes, while Henrry Rosario had an OPS well above everyone else. Barnes had competition from his own teammate, as Stetson Allie had a very strong month. In the end, we went with Barrett Barnes as the Pirates Prospect Player of the Month for July.

The reason we went with Barnes is because he his age appropriate for his level. He had slightly better stats than Allie, while also getting a little more playing time. He wasn’t far behind Logan Hill in overall stats, but Hill lost some luster when he was dropped from Bradenton to West Virginia this season. In Low-A, Hill is old for the level. Rosario had a great month, as shown by his stats below. The problem is that he is a 23-year-old playing in a league full of 18-20 year old players, while playing a level lower than he was at last year. Basically, he should be dominating at that level.

Before this season, Barnes had missed a lot of time since being drafted in 2012 due to injury. His career high for games played is 95 set last year, and he played 194 games total in his first four seasons. Those injuries caused him to miss a lot of development time, which made it tough to get a good read on his progress. He remained a top 30 prospect in the system due to the tools, and also the fact that we never saw what he could do when he was healthy over a long stretch. Three average/below average months to start this season dropped him in our mid-season top 50 prospect rankings.

Barnes is just two games short of his career high going into Tuesday night’s action. He had a decent month of May with a .765 OPS, but both April and June were below average months. He came into July with a season OPS of .690 and left the month with a .779 OPS, which puts him just a few points out of the top 20 in the Eastern League. Barnes hit .404/.457/.521 in 27 games. He had a streak of 22 games in which he reached base at least once.

We are starting to see some of the reasons why he was taken 45th overall in the 2012 draft. Barnes is driving the ball better, using his speed to take extra bases on balls hit into the gaps. His defense has shown signs of improving, which just goes along with him getting consistent playing time. He will never be the potential five-tool center fielder we heard as a ceiling when he was drafted. His arm is below average and he’s more suited for left field. The power really hasn’t shown up, but he is a strong player, who hits the ball well, so there is a possibility for plenty of extra-base hits.

The key for Barnes going forward will be his health and continuing to stay within his game. Driving the ball to all parts of the field and using his speed to his advantage. July was a glimpse of what got him drafted so high, now he needs to prove it wasn’t a fluke.


Indianapolis – Jose Osuna, LF/1B (.289/.333/.544, 96 PA, 4 HR)

Altoona – Barrett Barnes, LF (.404/.457/.521, 106 PA, 0 HR)

Bradenton – Elvis Escobar, OF (.353/.398/.471, 94 PA, 1 HR)

West Virginia – Logan Hill, OF (.315/.384/.607, 99 PA, 4 HR)

Morgantown – Will Craig, 3B (.293/.409/.440, 93 PA, 1 HR)

Bristol – Huascar Fuentes, 1B (.312/.379/.481, 87 PA, 2 HR)

GCL – Henrry Rosario, OF (.386/.461/.705, 102 PA, 4 HR)

IMPORTANT: You will need to update your password after the switch to the new server in order to log in and comment. Go to the Password Reset Page to change your password.


    • I trust the guys at this site due to their exposure to the players and track record of tending to be right on guys, but I did think this was healthy to read after how badly I felt about the trade

  1. Like IC Bob, I am interested to read how trading McGuire and Ramirez impacts rule 5 draft and 40 man roster.

    • Well the trades of Melancon and Niese were two players who wouldn’t have a spot next year vs two who will in Rivero and Bastardo. Liriano and Hutchison are a wash and Nova takes a spot this year, but won’t next year.

      So that leaves you with two players signed for next year and only Ramirez taken off. McGuire didn’t need to be added until after next season, so zero effect there.

      Which means these deals equal one less spot for next season

          • Any rumblings about who or what the list might be like? I’m assuming Rule V eligible guys, but who knows. I can’t judge value anymore in the MLB.

            • My assumption is that the Yankees have a list of players to choose from (possibly a list of who they can’t have) and they will take their time picking two of them. I think they just wanted to get rid of Nova. No real use for him, and on the Pirates’ side, they just needed a cheap filler. I would be surprised if anyone on our current top 28 is in the deal. Anyone after that wouldn’t really surprise me except Neverauskas and Santana because they are the two best relievers in the system by far (excluded anyone who is currently a starter of course)

Comments are closed.