First Pitch: If There Was a Minor League Season, Part 5

This is getting tougher.

Today we cover the hypothetical Bradenton position players.  The Pirates figure to have a logjam throughout class A, for both good and bad reasons.  Sticking with the hitters, you’ve got three principal categories that’ll impact the Marauders:  2018 college draftees, 2019 college draftees, and prep and international guys.

In an ideal world, prep and international prospects, or at least the better ones, will spend their first full US seasons in low A.  So far so good; several of the Pirates’ better prep and int’l position players have gone to Greensboro and done well, leaving them well positioned for Bradenton in 2020.

College hitters, on the other hand, ideally will go straight from the New York-Penn League, in that first, partial season, to high A.  On this front, not so good.  The 2018 guys nearly all went to GBO in 2019 and were overmatched.  Most didn’t even look ready for that level, much less the Florida State League.  Much the same happened with the 2019 college draftees.  A couple held their own in the NYPL and might merit a jump up to the FSL.  Others, I suppose, could get promoted strictly due to their draft slots and bonuses.  That potentially leaves a bunch of guys converging in the FSL.

As we’ve discussed many times, we have no clue how the new front office will approach promotion issues.  But, hey, this is my hypothetical MiL season, so I’m going to do what I want.  As many of you can probably guess, I’d prefer to see the Bucs move younger guys who are performing, if necessary at the expense of older guys who aren’t.


This is pretty much always a “yeah, whatever” position in this system.  As I’ve already mentioned, the Pirates have two MiL veterans and three glove-only catchers of their own at the upper levels.  That may force Deon Stafford back to Bradenton.  Stafford is a bat-first catcher who’s put up only so-so numbers the last two years.  That could leave him sharing the duties with Grant Koch who, like Stafford, is an offense-oriented catcher drafted in round five.  Koch managed only a .591 OPS in Low A in 2019, so that’s not good.  Zac Susi, a glove-only catcher drafted in round 12 in 2018, could also be with the Marauders.


Exactly how interesting the infield turns out to be could depend on the new regime’s willingness to dispense with the old FO’s practice of playing non-prospects at first base.  Under the old FO, we’d probably get Luke Mangieri, an org. guy who put up weak numbers at GBO in 2019.  Bradenton will likely have plenty of outfielders, though, so it’s hard to understand why the Pirates wouldn’t give reps at first to guys like Jack Herman, Fabricio Macias and Blake Sabol.  I’d far rather see their bats in the lineup every day than a non-prospect getting 400 PAs.

The third baseman should be Jared Triolo, selected last year in the supplemental second round.  Triolo’s good enough defensively that the Pirates gave him some time at short.  His numbers in the NYPL (239/314/389) were underwhelming, but the league as a whole hit a dismal 232/313/337.  Triolo was second in the league in doubles, so maybe some of those will start clearing the fence.

As for the middle infield, it’s pretty likely that Rodolfo Castro will be back at Bradenton, at least early on, so he’d play second.  This shortstop should be Ji-Hwan Bae, but here’s another crunch.  Connor Kaiser, drafted in round three in 2018, figures to be in the FSL after being overmatched (.656 OPS) in 2019 in the SAL.  Kaiser is currently better defensively than Bae, but he’s also three years older and Bae is an actual . . . you know . . . prospect.

Other Bradenton infielders could be Kyle Mottice and Adrian Valerio.  Mottice signed as a non-drafted free agent and has put up crazy OBPs, generally around .470.  I don’t know whether he can do that at upper levels — he has no power — but he should get some chances.  Valerio is an org. guy at this point.


The Marauders should have an interesting outfield.  They could have as many as five players there with at least some prospect potential, including Herman, Macias, Sabol, Jonah Davis and Lolo Sanchez.

Sanchez, of course, will be returning after struggling in the FSL in the second half of 2019.  Scouts seem pretty down on his swing, which is pull-heavy but doesn’t generate power.  His speed and defense make it worth giving him opportunities.

Herman is arguably the best prospect of the bunch.  He added some muscle last year and added some power, with two caveats:  he sacrificed a lot of contact to do it, and he had a large home/road split, which is concerning due to the very power-friendly environment at GBO.  The FSL, by contrast, sucks up power like a sponge.  Herman probably doesn’t profile as a center fielder, but he has a plus arm.

Macias was more solid than good at GBO last year, but he can play center and could go somewhere if his power develops a bit more.  Davis is something of a mini-Mason Martin, with good power numbers but scary contact issues.  He seemed to slow down last year and looks more like a corner guy than a center fielder.  Sabol, like Triolo, put up numbers in the NYPL (245/350/351) that looked weak until you check the league’s dismal hitting stats.  The Pirates could give him a shot at moving up to the FSL.

Finally, two other possibilities are Justin Harrer and Matt Gorski.  Harrer is probably an org. guy, but he’s shown some power and speed.  Gorski was the 57th overall pick in last year’s draft.  He looks like a legit CF, but he really struggled in the NYPL.  I suppose, though, that his $1M bonus could get him a bump to Bradenton.

So here’s what I’d like to see at Bradenton (the OFs would shift around a lot and I’m assuming Castro would earn an early promotion):

  1. Ji-Hwan Bae, SS/2B
  2. Jonah Davis, OF/DH
  3. Jack Herman, OF/1B/DH
  4. Jared Triolo, 3B
  5. Fabricio Macias, OF/1B/DH
  6. Blake Sabol, OF/1B/DH
  7. Deon Stafford, C
  8. Connor Kaiser, 2B/SS
  9. Lolo Sanchez, OF

Bench:  Grant Koch, Kyle Mottice, Luke Mangieri, Justin Harrer




By John Dreker

One game of note and three former Pittsburgh Pirates born on this date. We start with a Hall of Famer.

Bert Blyleven, pitcher for the 1978-80 Pirates. He began his Major League career in 1970 as a 19-year-old by going 10-9, 3.18 in 164 innings for the Minnesota Twins. At age 20 he won 16 games, threw 17 complete games and pitched a total of 278.1 innings. After winning 17 games in 1972, he put up an incredible season the next year. Blyleven made 40 starts in 1973, finished 25 of them and nine were shutouts. He pitched a total of 325 innings, winning 20 games for the only time in his career. From 1971 until 1976, he threw at least 275 innings every season. His lowest strikeout total during that six season stretch was 219 in 1976. In June of 1976 he was traded to the Texas Rangers. On December 8, 1977 the Pirates acquired him in a four-team trade involving 11 players.

After going 14-12, 2.72 in 30 starts during the 1977 season, Blyleven went 14-10, 3.03 in 34 starts with the Pirates in 1978. He pitched 243.2 innings that year and struck out 182 batters for the second straight season. In 1979 he posted his highest ERA up to that point, but for once he didn’t have to be perfect to get wins. He had pitched for some poor teams during his career, resulting in many .500 W/L seasons, despite always posting strong stats. In 1979 the Pirates won the World Series, and Blyleven went 12-5, 3.60 during the season and 2-0, 1.50 in three playoff games. In 1980 his ERA rose, his record dropped to 8-13 and he was unhappy in Pittsburgh. Blyleven was dealt to the Indians, along with Manny Sanguillen, on December 9, 1980. He went on to pitch another 11 seasons in the majors, finishing with a 287-250, 3.31 record in 4,970 innings, with 242 complete games, 60 shutouts and 3,701 strikeouts. He was voted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 2011 during his 14th year on the ballot.

Sonny Senerchia, third baseman for the 1952 Pirates. The Pirates signed him as an amateur free agent right out of Montclair State University in 1952. He had previously played minor league ball in 1949, prior to beginning his college career. After signing, Senerchia played 62 games in the Carolina League, where he hit .296 with seven homers. He joined the Pirates in late August, playing 28 games at third base and hitting .220 with three homers and 11 RBIs. Senerchia spent the entire 1953 season in the minors, playing for three different Pirates affiliates. He hit a combined .260 with 16 homers in 127 games. Following the season, the Pirates lost him to the St Louis Cardinals in the December 1953 Rule 5 draft. He played five more seasons without making it back to the majors before he retired. He was a pitcher during his last four seasons in pro ball.

Alex McRae, pitcher for the 2018-19 Pirates. He was a tenth round pick of the Pirates in 2014. McRae made it to the majors in 2018 for two games and he allowed four runs in 6.1 innings. He made 11 appearances in 2019, including two starts. He posted an 8.78 ERA in 26.2 innings. He was designated for assignment for the second time after the season and opted for free agency. McRae signed a minor league deal with the Chicago White Sox over the off-season.

On this date in 1971 the Pirates opened their regular season with a 4-2 win over the Philadelphia Phillies. Dock Ellis pitched a complete game, allowing eight hits, two walks, a hit batter and he struck out eight. He also drove in a run and dropped down three sacrifice bunts. Richie Hebner had two hits, a walk and an RBI. The lineup had three Hall of Famers for the Pirates. Bill Mazeroski went 1-for-3, with an RBI. Roberto Clemente had an 0-for-4 game. Willie Stargell was 1-for-4, with a run scored.

The lineup that day was as follows:

2B Mazeroski

3B Hebner

RF Clemente

C  Sanguillen

1B Robertson

LF Stargell

CF Oliver

SS Hernandez

P  Ellis

Having followed the Pirates fanatically since 1965, Wilbur Miller is one of the fast-dwindling number of fans who’ve actually seen good Pirate teams. He’s even seen Hall-of-Fame Pirates who didn’t get traded mid-career, if you can imagine such a thing. His first in-person game was a 5-4, 11-inning win at Forbes Field over Milwaukee (no, not that one). He’s been writing about the Pirates at various locations online for over 20 years. It has its frustrations, but it’s certainly more cathartic than writing legal stuff. Wilbur is retired and now lives in Bradenton with his wife and three temperamental cats.

Support Pirates Prospects

Related articles

join the discussion

Share article

Pirates Prospects Daily

Latest articles

Pirates Prospects Weekly

MONDAY: First Pitch

TUESDAY: Article Drop


THURSDAY: Roundtable

FRIDAY: Discussion

SATURDAY: Pirates Winter Report

SUNDAY: Pirates Business

Latest comments